Abstract | Table of Contents | Bibliography
OPENING THE LANCANG (MEKONG) RIVER IN YUNNAN:
PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS FOR XISHUANGBANNA
A Thesis Presented
MERRICK LEX BERMAN
Submitted to the Graduate School of the
University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment
of the requirements for the degree of
MASTER OF ARTS
Department of Asian Languages and Literatures
Donald E. Gjertson, Asian Languages and Literatures
Piper Rae Gaubatz, Geosciences
Lucien Miller, Comparative Literature
Ó Copyright by Merrick Lex Berman 1998
All Rights Reserved
Many thanks to Alvin Cohen and Cheng Ching-mao for years of encouragement and support. Also thanks to Lucien Miller for his kindness and enthusiasm. For their advice, comments, and information, I would also like to extend my gratitude to Piper Gaubatz, James Hafner, E. Bruce Brooks, Edwin Gentzler, and the late Prof. Tong Enzheng. As a recipient of a 1997-98 Fulbright research scholarship to Taiwan, I would also like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who made it possible for me to continue my research for this thesis and related topics on Southwest China's transport infrastructure, including Shen Zhongwei, Chen Chao-Zung, Wu Jying-jyi (and the whole FSE staff), with a special note of thanks to the Institute of History and Philology at Academia Sinica, Taiwan, for use of their computer and library facilities, and to my sponsor at Academia Sinica, Fan I Chun.
Regional cooperation to develop the Lancang (Mekong) River in China and five neighboring states of mainland Southeast Asia has swept the Chinese border region of Xishuangbanna Prefecture into a period of rapid change. Once an isolated region of lush tropical rain forest, Xishuangbanna will face increasing pressures of land, water, and air traffic; industrialization; urbanization; and subsequently risks of pollution, deforestation and environmental degradation. This study examines the plans for future development, the existing infrastructure, and the use of the river by the local residents, in order to identify the areas of greatest contact and possible conflict that will result from the opening of this international shipping corridor.
This study is divided into four sections, the first of which places the sudden interest in developing the Lancang (Mekong) corridor in its current international context. As the six countries of the Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) have begun to cooperate on economic development, they have found increasing support from both regional and international organizations. Although a variety of basic infrastructure projects have already been agreed upon in the transport, energy, tourism, telecom-munications, and human resource development sectors, one of the projects which has already made considerable headway is the opening of the shipping corridor on the Lancang (Mekong) River. During the last two years, new border agreements and navigation agreements have opened the flow of trade goods along the route from Xishuangbanna in the north, to Chiang Khong, Thailand and Huay Xai, Laos in the south.
In the second part of this study, the physical geography of the river basin, as well as its existing transport and energy infrastructure will be looked at in greater detail. The soaring cliffs, rapids, and surging currents which characterize the northern reaches of the Lancang River in China preclude any navigation except at a few protected ferry crossings, while the widening of the river and lessening of the degree of slope makes the Xishuangbanna region the farthest north that navigation has traditionally been able to penetrate.
The history and economy of Xishuangbanna are examined in the third part of this study, focusing on the Dai kingdom which dominated the area for many centuries. The Dai people of Xishuangbanna, with their highly developed social and political structures, were the northern members of a network of four loosely associated Dai kingdoms. With the formation of modern "states," borders divided the four kingdoms into the territories of China, Laos, Thailand and Myanmar, and then the Dai people were further isolated by the Communist consolidation of the Yunnan frontier. Although they have been forced to dissociate themselves from their cross-border neighbors for many decades, the Dai people are now being held up as models for the traditional "ethnic trade," which is supposed to form a cultural and linguistic basis for the booming border trade now sweeping Yunnan.
The fourth section of this study will evaluate and compare the various points of view being expressed by the Chinese authors writing on the subject of opening up Yunnan's border regions to international trade and tourism. This section will focus on the inconsistent objectives that have been set forth to open up the Lancang (Mekong) corridor, (for example, the contradictions implicit in a policy of connecting ethnicity and trade), and will contrast the sensibilities of Yunnan native authors with national level development and policy experts, and provide a background for analysis of emerging trends throughout the region. Such trends include the impact of world market forces, urbanization, and tourism on the local society. In conclusion, the effects of shipping traffic on the Lancang River ecology will be considered and contrasted with the philosophy of preserving Yunnan's natural environment by developing eco-tourism. As an appendix to the main text, the latter position on nature conservation will be spelled out by a complete translation of Yang Fuquan's 1995 article, "Eco-Tourism and the Protection of Yunnan's Tourist Resources."
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ABSTRACT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
PREFACE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LIST OF FIGURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LIST OF MAPS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I. NEW WAVE OF INTEREST IN DEVELOPING THE LANCANG (MEKONG) REGION
A. Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) Cooperation . . . . .
1. Growth of Border Trade Between China and the Mekong Countries . . . . . . .
2. Emerging Players in GMS Development . . . . . .
B. Opening the Lancang (Mekong) River . . . . . . . . .
C. Endnotes to Chapter I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
A. Geography of the Lancang Basin . . . . . . . . . .
B. Transport on the Lancang River . . . . . . . . . .
1. Bridges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2. Ferries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3. Existing River Transport . . . . . . . . . .
C. Industrial and Energy Infrastructure . . . . . . . . .
1. Energy Sector . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2. Industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
D. Endnotes to Chapter II . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
III. THE PEOPLES, HISTORY, AND ECONOMY OF XISHUANGBANNA (XSBN)
A. The Xishuangbanna Dai People . . . . . . . . . . . .
1. Historical Background . . . . . . . . . . . .
2. Social Organization of the Dai-Lue Kingdom . . . .
3. Network of Dai Kingdoms . . . . . . . . . . .
B. Formation of Modern Borders . . . . . . . . . . .
C. Communist Consolidation . . . . . . . . . . . .
D. Ethnicity and Trade . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1. Background of "Ethnic" Border Trade in XSBN . . . . . .
2. Ethnic Trade as a Key to Opening the Border . . . . .
E. Endnotes to Chapter III . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IV. SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES OF DEVELOPMENT
A. Labor Issues in the Border Region . . . . . . . . . .
B. Poverty and Economic Development . . . . . . . . .
1. Strategies for Economic Growth . . . . . . . .
2. Transport Sector as a Key to Growth . . . . . .
C. The Trend Toward Urbanization . . . . . . . . . . .
D. Meeting of the "Frontier" and the World Economy . . . . .
E. Tourism and Opening XSBN . . . . . . . . . . .
F. River Ecology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
G. Use of the Lancang River in Dai Society . . . . . . .
1. Shipping . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2. Bathing, Washing and Fishing . . . . . . . .
I. Endnotes to Chapter IV . . . . . . . . . . . . .
APPENDIX: "ECO-TOURISM AND THE PROTECTION OF YUNNAN'S TOURISM RESOURCES" by Yang Fuquan
A. Notes for Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
BIBLIOGRAPHY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LIST OF FIGURES
1. China - Myanmar Trade fig1.jpg
2. China Trade With GMS Countries fig2.jpg
3. River Crossing at China - Viet Nam Border fig3.jpg
4. China - Thailand Trade fig4.jpg
5. Kawagarbo Mountain Towers Over the Upper Lancang fig5.jpg
6. Cliffs Along the Upper Lancang and Its Tributary Streams fig6.jpg
7. The Lancang Valley South of Yongping fig7.jpg
8. Giant Banyan in XSBN's Forest Near Daluo fig8.jpg
9. Length and Drainage of Lancang / Mekong fig9.jpg
10. Goatskin Rafts For Crossing the Yangzi In Northern Yunnan fig10.jpg
11. Woven Bridge Over the Dulong River In Yunnan fig11.jpg
12. Rope Bridge Across the Upper Mekong fig12.jpg
13. Greasing a Rope Bridge with Yak Butter On the Way Across fig13.jpg
14. Horses Being Slung Across the Mekong and Salween Rivers fig14.jpg
15. Iron Bridge Across the Yangpi River fig15.jpg
16. Ship Service at Guanlei, XSBN fig16.jpg
17. Myanmar Inland Water Freight Volume and Containers Handled fig17.jpg
18. Hydropower Stations on the Lancang River, Existing and Proposed Development fig18.jpg
19. Manwan Hydropower Station fig19.jpg
20. The Jinghong Bridge Over the Lancang fig20.jpg
21. Yunnan Forward Position Border Processing Bases and Mekong Subregion Urban Populations fig21.jpg
22. Traditional Dai Architecture fig22.jpg
23. Traditional Mekong Rafts fig23.jpg
24. Bathing in the Lancang River fig24.jpg
25. Washing Vegetables in the Lancang River fig25.jpg
26. Huayao Dai Women Dragging For Fish fig26.jpg
LIST OF MAPS
1. The Lancang (Mekong) River in China and Southeast Asia map1.jpg
2. The Lancang River in Yunnan not available
3. River Transport in Xishuangbanna not available
4. Hydropower Development on the Lancang River not available
5. Surface Transport and Airports in XSBN Region not available
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
ADB Asian Development Bank
ASEAN Association of Southeast Asian Nations
CFFA China, Facts & Figures Annual.
DZSH Daizu shehui lishi diaocha: Xishuangbanna.
EIU Economist Intelligence Unit
ESCAP Economic & Social Commission for Asia & the Pacific (U.N.)
FBIS Foreign Broadcast Information Service
FEA Far East and Australia.
FEER Far East Economic Review.
GMS Greater Mekong Subregion
GTJJ Xishuangbanna guotu jingji kaocha baogao.
MRC Mekong River Commission
MZYJ Minzu yanjiu gongzuo de yuejin.
NGO Non-Governmental Organization
SLORC State Law and Order Restoration Committee (Myanmar)
TAT Tourism Authority of Thailand
TYPN Thai Yunnan Project Newsletter.
UNDP United Nations Development Program
YNDZ Yunnan di zhou shi xian gaikuang.
NEW WAVE OF INTEREST IN DEVELOPING THE LANCANG (MEKONG) REGION
A. Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) Cooperation
For more than half a century, many plans have been put forward to harness the Mekong (also known as the Lancang), the vital river that rolls down from the mountains of central China and links all five countries of mainland Southeast Asia. Due to the political and social turmoil that has shaken the entire region for many decades, the majority of these development programs were put on hold, while the development that did take place often resulted in the deforestation and further degradation of the river basin, rather than in improving it.1
During the last several years, the Mekong has once again become a focus of attention as the six riparian countries of the Mekong (Cambodia, China, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam) have found a mutual advantage in opening up the river basin for development, and are working to establish subregional economic cooperation in a political environment that promises some degree of stability. The basic change in the region has been the sudden growth of border trade, and the promise of shorter, cheaper connections between China and its southwestern neighbors. If the Mekong can be opened up for transport of raw materials, agricultural products, manufactured goods, and passengers, then a new engine to drive the regional economy can be created and the recent boom of trade with the landlocked Chinese province, Yunnan, can be sustained. (MAP ONE)
1. Growth of Border Trade Between China and the Mekong Countries
Toward the end of the 1980's, unofficial border trade increased significantly in
Yunnan. This revival and the subsequent boom of China's trade with Southeast Asia followed decades of unsettled relations, during which the establishment and discontinuation of trade relations proceeded like a wild roller coaster ride over a series of political upheavals.
For example, a boom in trade with Myanmar began in 1987, with the beginning of the Burma Socialist Program Party's liberalization of foreign and domestic trade policies.2 Burma's trade with China rose by 72% over the previous year. In 1988, when the ruling junta, the State Law and Order Restoration Committee, or SLORC, officially opened the border to trade with China, trade jumped up another 65%.3 (See fig1.jpg)
In the case of Laos, which had been receiving technical assistance from China for the construction of the "Mao Zedong Road" in Phong Saly during the 60's and 70's,4 relations with China deteriorated in 1978, when Laos showed support for Viet Nam. Full diplomatic relations between Vientiane and Beijing were not reestablished until May 1988.5 Although the volume of trade between China and Laos does not rank them as significant trading partners, nonetheless a strategic interest in developing the surface routes in northern Laos, remains.6
As for border trade with Viet Nam, official trade at the Hekou / Laokai port was suspended by the Sino-Viet War of 1979, and was not officially reopened until May, 1993.7 Reflecting the gap in official relations, no trade figures for Viet Nam were listed in China's Statistical Yearbook from 1980 to 1990. Trade had already shifted into high gear by the time normalization of relations was announced in November of 1991,8 and has been soaring ever since. (See fig2.jpg) The craze in border trade with Viet Nam has rapidly overwhelmed the existing infrastructure, causing huge bottlenecks at the official crossings. Although the rail crossing at Hekou / Laokai has was re-opened by 1994, and the rail gauge was widened to a one-meter standard, it has not recaptured it's former significance as the lifeline between Hanoi and Kunming. In 1993, the majority of traffic was being run across the Nanxi River by ferry boat and reloaded onto lorries at the other side (see fig3.jpg),9 but by late 1997, unofficial trade was no longer in evidence and had been replaced by regulated daily crossings of trains, trucks, and pedestrians.
If we take into account China's trade relations with Thailand, (formally established in 1975), then the urgent interest to open up a low cost shipping route between the two countries becomes perfectly clear. Combined imports and exports for 1992 and 1993 exceeded US$ 1.4 billion.10 In 1994, the trade volume skyrocketed above the US$ 2 billion mark, an increase of 50% over the previous year. (See fig4.jpg) Since the vast majority of this trade is conducted by shipping across thousands of miles of sea lanes, and is further obstructed by backlogs in the domestic rail network in China, both sides see advantages in the Lancang (Mekong) corridor, particularly for Chinese exports of raw materials produced in Yunnan or the greater southwest.11 In this sense the Lancang (Mekong) is viewed as an engine to drive north-south trade and investment.
During the 1990's, yet another factor impacted several of the Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) countries. Viet Nam, Laos, and Cambodia were forced to seek out new partners when the trading arrangements of their former top trading partners -- the Soviet Union and Eastern European countries -- suddenly fell into disarray.12 This only served to increase the momentum of unifying the subregional economy, and was a motivating force for the ratification of new border treaties. A Lao-Chinese treaty signed in December 1993, formally established the border line (of 416km) surveyed the previous year. As for the border between Myanmar and Laos, formed by the Mekong River, and which runs south from China to Thailand, the demarcation of it's 263 km length was not officially established until October 1995.13
The resolution of these border disputes has created a tremendous potential for the formation of a greater "economic quadrangle," sometimes called the "golden quadrangle," which would link some 50 million people in a vast region of 600,000 square kilometers.14 This "golden quadrangle," juxtaposed with some irony on top of the "golden triangle," is just another name that has been invented to portray the economic forces already at work in the subregion. The momentum for cooperation that is building up among the GMS governments is also drawing considerable interest in private business circles, such as the launching of a mutual investment fund in Singapore,15 and the founding of the Economic Quadrangle Joint Development Company.16
As one researcher, Mark Nguyen, puts it:
2. Emerging Players in GMS Development
As the Mekong region faces the possibility of major new infrastructure projects being launched, many forces are drawn into the picture. Within China there are national level policies and security issues involved, and yet, interestingly, it has been Yunnan Province, not Beijing that has been participating in the subregional development conferences.
In this respect, it is not surprising that the governor of Yunnan Province, He Zhiqiang, outlined a plan to develop the "Lancang Economic Belt" in May, 1993. The plan called for developing mining operations in the mountainous upper section of the river basin; to concentrate on building hydropower stations and wood processing facilities in the middle section; and to open up the lower section passing through Xishuangbanna (XSBN) to international shipping.18 The announcement coincided with an expedition undertaken by a China, Laos, Myanmar, Thai joint observation group, which had been surveying the Lancang (Mekong) from February to May of the same year. And though Yunnan's governor seemed to be taking the lead in proposing the Lancang Economic Belt, his comments were echoed by the Chinese Premier, Li Peng, who had been in attendance at the Yunnan provincial government meetings where the policy was drafted.19
On the local level, there is little evidence of officials in XSBN taking part in the planning of the new regional agenda.20 As for the people living in the areas where there is likely to be the greatest social and environmental impact, there isn't even a shred of information available. In stark contrast, international support for developing the Mekong is gathering steam, busily concocting huge road networks and energy grids all over the map.
Beginning in 1992, a series of conferences and deliberations have been held among the six GMS countries with the aim of coordinating their infrastructure investments. By the time of the 4th conference (September 1994),21 the momentum had built up to the point of implementing priority projects, and the beginnings of an institutional base to sustain the process of subregional cooperation was already being formed.
With institutional support from the Asian Development Bank (ADB), the United Nations Development Program (UNDP), the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP), the Tourism Authority of Thailand (TAT), and the Mekong River Committee (MRC), a new wave of interest in developing the GMS is gathering strength.
In May 1996, the ADB extended a technical assistance grant of US$800,000 to provide training in areas of concern (from a regional perspective) on environmental problems.22 At the August 1996 conference, held in Kunming, (provincial capital of Yunnan,) the ADB vice president, Bong-Suh Lee, announced the extension of US$300 million in loans, the most substantial economic backing for the GMS projects so far, and which was referred to as merely "seed money," to attract much larger investments.23
Educational support has appeared in the form of the "Institute of Economic Development and Cooperation", established in a memorandum of understanding between the governments of Thailand and New Zealand in August 1996. The Institute is now located at Khon Kaen University and trains managers from the public and private sectors of the participating GMS countries.24 Although not directly involved with the GMS development projects, considerable contributions to the study of the upper Mekong have been made by the Thai-Yunnan Project of Australian National University and the Upper Mekong Research Project, funded by the Australian Research Council.25
In addition to the support of these agencies, a recent meeting between the newly revived MRC26 and representatives of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) in Kuala Lumpur suggests that more support from neighboring countries, such as Malaysia, might:
which would have far-reaching consequences for the region in terms of capital for investment and industrial growth.
As grants, loans, and private funds gravitate toward the GMS projects, inevitable choices will be made as to which sectors will be developed first. The main sectors, for which detailed projects were discussed and recommended at the 3rd conference on subregional development (April 1994), were transport, energy, environment, trade & investment, and tourism. To these should probably be added telecommunications, which became a high priority at the GMS meeting held in Phnom Penh (July 1996).28 Since many of the infrastructure projects will require huge capital investments, and long periods of time for completion, the earliest signs of progress have been seen in the Water Transport Subsector's "Upstream Lancang (Mekong) River Navigation Improvement Project", a project which not only requires a comparatively low initial investment, but which was already partially underway as early as 1990.29
B. Opening the Lancang (Mekong) River
On the short list of priority GMS projects, the opening of the Lancang (Mekong) River, which will connect China's Yunnan Province to Thailand via Laos and Myanmar, is at the very top. In China, the navigable section of the Lancang passes through Xishuangbanna Autonomous Prefecture (XSBN), the highly variegated terrain of intermontane basins near the southwestern border of Yunnan Province. The Mekong basin area to the south of China, comprising part of the infamous Golden Triangle (Myanmar, Thailand, Laos), has been isolated not only by ongoing insurrections but also by miserable roads, total lack of communications, and deliberate political and military containment.30 In the optimistic terminology of the GMS projects, it has been re-christened the Golden Quadrangle, connecting China, Laos, Myanmar, and Thailand. Nonetheless, without great capital investments in infrastructure, the Golden Quadrangle will be unable to link up a network of surface roads in the near future.31
River traffic, on the other hand, has been the basic means of transport in this area for ages.32 Though impeded by rapids and falls, which made the Mekong impassable to larger ships, there is no question that local residents, familiar with the dangerous spots, could navigate on small craft in the intervening sections, stopped only by the tremendous force of the current.33 More importantly, despite the difficulties of navigation, and the negligible volume of commercial traffic:
Therefore, it is important to keep in mind that the river remains a lifeline for the residents of the basin when considering the means and objectives of enlarging the traffic into a major corridor for international shipping and transport.
Building on the volume of small-scale traffic, which has arguably been in existence for ages, China and Laos began joint surveys and tests of the route between Jinghong and Huay Xai in 1990. Shortly after the 1st GMS conference in Oct 1992, a survey team was formed of geographers, hydrologists, and technicians from China, Laos, Thailand and Myanmar, who conducted a series of joint surveys and tests along the international shipping route during the spring of 1993. Meanwhile, the political representatives of the four governments, have succeeded in creating a legal framework for river transport, and established an administrative committee to address navigational issues on the Lancang (Mekong) in January 1994.35 In October 1994, a "free navigation" agreement was agreed upon by senior officials of the four nations, which officially opened up four ports in China, two ports in Myanmar, five ports in Laos, and two ports in Thailand to navigation by one another's ships.36 An "experimental" shipment of apples from Jinghong to Chiang Saen Thailand took place in 1995, the same year which showed a dramatic rise in reported shipments along the route, from 500 tons in 1991, to 40,000 tons in 1995.37
The cost-effective link between China and three adjacent countries has led to greatly increased traffic on the Mekong, and proposed improvements, which include blasting rapids and shoals with dynamite, seek to increase the year-round capacity of the route to accommodate 100-300 ton vessels.
But just as the opening of the Lancang gains momentum, and a host of other infrastructure projects in the GMS are beginning to be implemented,38 there is a corresponding need to evaluate the ecological and social impact that they will have on both the river and the residents of the region. Some work of this type already exists for the downstream parts of the Mekong,39 but very little has been done on the upstream part of the river, which spills from glacier-covered mountains of Tibet and reaches tropical rain forests along the international border.
As the Lancang (Mekong) route is upgraded and linked to ports and road networks downstream, economic, ecological, and social impacts will effect areas along the river basin. This study will focus on one section of the Lancang River: the 180 km section that flows through XSBN Autonomous Prefecture, in Yunnan Province, China. The existing environmental, economic, and social conditions in the Lancang basin of XSBN will be examined in order to assess the potential impacts of opening the region to international traffic.
C. Endnotes to Chapter I
1. The causes of deforestation are many, and though it is hard to say whether development, the destruction caused by war, or clearing of land for housing and agriculture are the worst contributors, nonetheless, the loss of forest land in the Mekong region has been disastrous. Cambodia has lost more than 50% of its forest cover since the 1960's; Vietnam's forest cover has dropped from 44% to 24% during the last five decades; the northeastern part of Thailand, Isan, saw a drop of forest cover from 65% in 1951 to merely 8% in 1985....estimates for the entire Mekong basin show a decline from about 50% in 1970 to only 27% in 1985, with consequent problems of erosion and flooding. See: Jacobs, 1995: 137. Another example of degradation is found in the Pak Mool Dam, which was completed in 1991 and has resulted in the bankruptcy of several thousand fisherman. See a related article in Thai Development Newsletter, no. 26 (1994): 11-13.
2. FEA, 1995: 627.
3. A summary of Sino-Burmese trade is found in Chen, 1995. In the preceding decades, trade relations had been destabilized by the activities of a Chinese-funded Burmese Communist Party (BCP), not to mention a series of armed insurgencies and the constant presence of sophisticated opium producers and their private armies. The turmoil of the 1967 protests in Yangoon and the founding of the BCP are detailed in Pettman, 1973: 32-39. The insurgencies in Myanmar are recounted in Lintner, 1990. For a full account of the drug trade in Southeast Asia, see McCoy, 1991: 162-192, 283-386.
4. Yang, 1993: 8.
5. FEA, 1995: 513-514.
6. Safe travel through northern Laos remains an elusive goal, and the prospect of the quiet historic capital, Luang Prabang, becoming a truck stop between the greater economic powers in Kunming and Thailand is viewed by some observers with great ambivalence. See Lintner, 1996.
7. FBIS CHI-93-094 (May 18, 1993): 14.
8. FEA, 1995: 1013.
9. See Zhang, 1993.
10. FEA, 1995: 992.
11. A new rail line between Kunming and Nanning, (opened Jan 1998,) will improve access to the South China Sea, and will significantly increase shipping access between Yunnan and ports in Thailand and South Asia. As for construction of more direct surface connections, improvement of the Jinghong-Tachilek-Mae Sai road is underway, but presently cannot match the carrying capacity for bulk cargo of the Mekong. According to Liu Daqing, of Yunnan's Transport Bureau, Navigation Section, the bottlenecks in the rail networks linking Yunnan to various seaports are so severe that Yunnan is faced with as much as a 50% gap in export capacity. He estimates: "By the year 2000, the two (landlocked) provinces of Yunnan and Guizhou, just in terms of phosphorous and coal, will have an export shortfall of at least 8.7 million tons, a very serious situation...and since the roads are not good enough for long-distance hauling, it makes the development of the Lancang shipping route -- 'facing South Asia, join the competition' mian xiang nan ya, can jia jing zheng-- rise before our eyes as vitally important." Author's translation of Liu, 1991: 508.
12. Tan, et al, 1995: 226.
13. Nguyen, 1996: 200-201.
14. Parts of Thailand, Myanmar, Laos, and Yunnan comprise the "golden square" jin si jiao A Description of the "golden quadrangle" is found in Tang, et al, 1995: 32.
15. The Crosby Fund, offered by Crosby Asset Management. See (Singapore) Business Times, (May 17, 1996) (via Lexis Nexis).
16. Nguyen, 1996: 204.
17. Nguyen, 1996: 199.
18. FBIS CHI-93-063 (Apr 5,1993).
19. FBIS CHI-93-092 (May 14, 1993), and FBIS CHI-93-096 (May 20, 1993). This is confirmed by the May 28th, Central News Agency article: "Premier Li Peng, from the highest strategic level, approved all of Yunnan's proposals to establish the Lancang basin as a vital national district for development and opening up." In Qiao bao (May 29, 1993): 4. The article describes Li Peng, Premier of China's State Council, as participating in the Yunnan Provincial government's formulation of a policy to establish the Lancang as a "foreign directed economic belt."
20. The Prefectural governor of XSBN, Zhao Cunxin, wrote an article on developing the Lancang [Zhao, 1991]. His long-term plan called for creating a tropical resources base in XSBN, as well as developing tourism, hydropower, and river transport. His views largely reflected the official government policy and were, if anything, very conservative. On the other end of the spectrum, the vice-mayor of Jinghong, Dao Yumin, is promoting more direct surface connections from Yunnan, through the Burmese Shan states to Thailand. Citing the surrender of the drug-baron, Khun Sa, in January of 1996, Dao suggested that a route south from Jinghong through Damenglong and the Myanmar towns of Mong Yawng, Mong Hpayak, and Tachilek to Mae Sai is now feasible. Dao said that a new border crossing would be opened on the route in January 1997. See: "China Pushes New Route to Thailand," in Straights Times, (November 11, 1996): 25 (via LexisNexis).
21. Held in Chiang Mai, 15-16 September, 1994. See: Asian Development Bank, 1994b.
22. Reported in Bangkok Post (May 24,1996) (via LexisNexis).
23. At the Aug 1996 GMS conference, held in Kunming, the ADB vice president, Bong-Suh Lee said that ADB had prepared US$300 million in loans to invest in the region during the next three years, calling the GMS the "last frontier of economic development....We can expect such investment to grow rapidly and reach a target of at least $1.3 billion by the turn of the century." Gunther Hecker of the ADB's transport and communications section said, "The $300 million is the trigger element for others to follow. We lay the seeds." Reported by Reuters (August 30, 1996) (via Clarinet).
24. New Zealand has pledged NZ$10 million (US$7 mil), and Thailand has pledged another 5 million baht (US$250,000) of funding for the institute. Reported by Agence France Presse, (August 281996) (via LexisNexis). In February, 1997, the Institute was officially opened in Khon Kaen, Thailand.
25. The only journal devoted to studies of the society, economy, and linguistics of the Dai and Thai people living in the upper Mekong region is the Thai Yunnan Project Newsletter (TYPN), founded in 1987. Edited by Gehan Wijeyewardene, the TYPN is published by the Department of Anthropology, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University, and is available on the internet at ftp.coombs.anu.edu. The Upper Mekong Research Project was established in 1991, when co-directors E.C. Chapman (Director, National Thai Studies Centre, Australia National University) and Peter Hinton (Anthropology Department, University of Sydney) were awarded a grant from the Australian Research Council. See: TYPN 17 (June, 1992): 30.
26. The history of the MRC is recounted in Jacobs, 1995.
27. Reported by Straights Times (Singapore), (September 8, 1996) (via LexisNexis).
28. Reported by Reuters (August 5, 1996) (via LexisNexis).
29. According to the Yunnan Yearbook 1992, "Building on the foundations of a 1990 China/Laos joint survey of the river during dry season, and shipping trials with cargo-laden vessels that tested the Lancang --Mekong shipping route, on August 2nd, 1991, three ships loaded with 155 tons of garlic, cement, and other goods cast off from Jinghong, sailed for 402km, and arrived at Huay Xai, Huoa Kong, Laos on Aug 6th. There they took on a load of 30 tons of ground coffee and returned to Jinghong." Author's translation from Yunnan nianjian, 1992: p253.
30. For a description of the physical conditions of the Shan states in Myanmar, see Bertil Lintner's account of his travels: Lintner, 1990.
31. Road projects are listed in Asian Development Bank, 1994a.
32. The Chinese sources consulted for this study, with one exception (Yao, 1948), unanimously state that river traffic on the Lancang did not exist before the establishment of steam-powered ferries in the 1950's. On the other hand, Western visitors to Jinghong consistently report the use of 50-foot long pirogues. See, for example, Colquhuon, 1885: 98.
33. At Nan'akou, on the Chinese border, the annual average flow rate has been measured at 2020 cubic meters per second [data from Liu, 1991: 513]. Since hand-
poled pirogues were the usual river craft of the villages along the Mekong in upper Laos, [Halpern, 1961: 32], there must have been limits beyond which the craft could not be pushed, though there remained the option of towing or portage. According to one 19th century observer, "...poling...dug-outs against the stream of the Me Kawng...between the worst rapids a good three miles an hour is kept up...in many places the boats are unloaded and hauled over by ropes, an occupation in which a day or two is often expended." [Smyth, 1898: (v.1) 161]. According to the same author, from Jinghong to Luang Prabang "the actual journey need only occupy five days; the journey up, from twelve to fifteen..." [Smyth, 1898: (v.1) 164]. See an account of a 1940's journey on the Lancang, translated below in Chapter IV, "Use of the Lancang River in Dai Society."
34. Halpern, 1961: 33.
35. Asian Development Bank, 1994: 147.
36. The ports opened were:
China: Jinghong, Simao, Menghan, Nan'ahe.
Myanmar: Wan Seng [100° 35'E by 20° 50'N], Wan Pong.
Laos: Ban Say, Xieng Kok, Moaung Mom, Huay Xai, Luang Prabang.
Thailand: Chiang Saen, and Chiang Khong.
Reported by Nusara Thaitawat, Bangkok Post, 13 Oct 94 (via LexisNexis).
37. See: Business Vietnam, (September 1996) (via LexisNexis).
38. See the full list of Transport Sector Projects in Asian Development Bank, 1994a: 89.
39. The Nam Pong post-audit study, conducted in the mid-70s, is perhaps the most comprehensive examination undertaken on the economic, social, & environmental impacts of a multipurpose reservoir in the Mekong region. It was built at Nam Pong, Thailand [102° 50' E by 16° 45' N] and opened in 1966. See: Jacobs, 1995: 144-45. Other basic research on the basin related to Mekong development can be found in Fujioka, 1966.
THE LANCANG RIVER: GEOGRAPHY AND INFRASTRUCTURE
A. Geography of the Lancang Basin
The Lancang River originates in eastern Tibet or Qinghai, where its highest tributaries wind down the valleys of the Tang'gula Mountains.1 In the Xikang region of eastern Tibet, the upper reaches are known as Zachu or Za'emuchu. Near the border town of Xika, (29° N by 98 25E), the Lancang enters Yunnan and plunges through deep gorges, hemmed in on both sides by mountains. (MAP TWO (not online))
The same tectonic collision between the South Asian and Eurasian continental plates that forms the Himalaya, causes an abrupt fold in the topography in the north-western part of Yunnan, and forms a series of north / south ranges there known as the Hengduan Mountains. The highest mountain in Yunnan, Kawagarbo, is found here. Towering 6,740 meters over the west bank of the Lancang River, Kawagarbo's east face is covered with a giant glacier.2 (See fig5.jpg) On the east bank of the river, across from Kawagarbo, is Dê qê n, the highest elevation county seat in Yunnan, at some 3,480 meters.3 In this formidable terrain, where the water rushes down narrow chasms strewn with boulders, hundreds of meters below the nearest footpath, it is easy to understand why river transport was not developed.4 (See fig6.jpg)
The Lancang flows south from Kawagarbo, through the Dulong Gorge5 and continues nearly due south for hundreds of kilometers, hemmed in by mountain ranges with peaks of 3,000 to 4,000 meters. At Yongping, the north / south mountain ranges break up into smaller, differentiated ranges with peaks of 2,000 to 2,500 meters, and the river makes a bend southeastward. (See fig7.jpg)
Along its southeastward course below Yongping, the mountains on the east bank are higher than those on the west bank. Reaching the Wuliang Mountains, the Lancang turns due south again, and begins a winding course that forms the border between Lincang and Simao Prefectures. Below the port town of Xiaoganlanba, the river enters XSBN Prefecture, flanked on the west by high plains at 1,050 to 1,200 meters elevation, and with mountain peaks in the range of 1,600 to 2,200 meters. To the east of the river are a convoluted series of very fragmented mountains ranging in height from 1,200 to 1,500 meters, among which are many bazi,6 or basins at an average elevation of 550-610 meters.
The valley of the Lancang basin, stretching from Xiaoganlanba south to Nan'ahekou at the Myanmar border, has ranges of 1,100 to 1,400 meters on both banks, and gorges of 300 to 500 meters. The climate of this region is primarily subject to the Indian monsoon, and its mountains were once covered with lush rain forest. In addition to cultivated tropical crops such as fruits, rubber, aromatics, and tea, XSBN's native flora has been preserved in networks of deep, zigzagging valleys. XSBN's treasure house of botanical diversity, though much depleted in recent decades, still offers a tremendous resource for botanical research and eco-tourism if carefully preserved.7 (See fig8.jpg)
South of the Chinese border, the Lancang River is known as the Mekong, or "mother of waters," and flows through Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam, before finally merging into the South China Sea at the Mekong River Delta south of Ho Chi Minh City. A comparison of the Mekong and Lancang sections of the river reveals that roughly half of the river's length lies in each, but that the drainage area in mainland Southeast Asia is approximately four times as large as the estimated drainage area in China. Of the drainage area inside China, Yunnan's accounts for more than 50%. (See fig9.jpg)
B. Transport on the Lancang River
Knowledge of transport on the Lancang River in the northern half of Yunnan is aided by early Chinese accounts,8 by the records of the Dali Nanzhao Kingdom,9 and by numerous accounts of both colonial period and modern explorers, most notably Joseph Rock, F. Kingdon Ward, and deCarne.10 There are accounts of notable crossings of the Yangzi, Lancang, and Nujiang, either by bamboo rafts or inflated skin-floats, usually as part of a military campaign and undertaken with great loss of life. Eyewitness accounts of upstream crossings are found in the works of Joseph Rock, who lived in northern Yunnan for nearly twenty years and left detailed maps and photographs of his numerous expeditions.11 (See fig10.jpg)
The available evidence suggests that fords and crossings of the rivers existed at various favorable points, that crossings were in many cases seasonal and dependent on conditions of weather and current, and that they were both arduous and extremely dangerous.12 This is further supported by the numerous bridges found all along the steep valleys and gorges of northern and western Yunnan, of the sort which proliferated throughout Burma, Tibet, and the greater Himalayan region. (See fig11.jpg)
Bridges are widely used throughout the upper Lancang region. The simplest type of bridge technology employed to cross the wild rivers were rope slide bridges, along which entire caravans---piece by piece, horse after horse---were slung from one side of the rocky chasm to the other. (See fig12.jpg) The average bridge:
In addition to rope bridges, iron chain bridges were built on the key caravan routes.14 These are found primarily in the Nanzhao sphere of influence around the modern town of Dali. Some ruins of iron bridges are found southwest of Dali, spanning the Yangbi River on the road to Yongping, and across the Lancang between Yongping and Baoshan. (See fig15.jpg) The ruins of a strategic iron bridge northwest of Lijiang, on the caravan route to Tibet are found on the Yangzi river near Qicong.15
Although Chinese scholars writing on the subject of developing the river do not mention transport on the Lancang before modern times, rope bridges are not used south of the Wuliang Shan area, where the width of the river, and the variable height of the banks make them impractical. Without bridges, how did anyone get across?
Based on a map from 1945, a decade before mechanized shipping appeared on the lower Lancang, there were nine ferry crossings marked in the Chinese section of the river below 24° N, while none were marked for the section above 24° N.16 Since the number of ferry crossings increases dramatically along the lower Lancang, we must assume that some form of navigation did exist there. The gap in Chinese records and observations can be explained by the fact that the Chinese did not actually occupy the XSBN region until the 1950's.17
Since the introduction of mechanized ferries in 1955, stations at Yunjinghong, Ganlanba, Menglun, Guanlei, and Simao have gone into operation. Several ports have been expanded and rebuilt, including the new Xiaoganlanba Port, which can handle 80,000 tons and 150,000 passengers annually.18
In the village of Guanlei, workers ride the ferry upriver to seek employment, then float back down river on tire inner-tubes, and the townspeople hurry on board to purchase daily necessities whenever the boat arrives.19 (See fig16.jpg) The example of Guanlei, suggests that the vital commercial connection provided by shipping services is the only means of communication for some of the mountain regions. Inaccessible by road, especially during the long rainy season, these conditions duplicate those found on the nearby sections of the Mekong in Laos and Myanmar, where people in the riverine communities travel on the river in pirogues (with or without outboard motors), river barges, and rafts.20 (MAP THREE (not online))
3. Existing River Transport
Beginning in 1955, when the first ferry capable of carrying automobiles went into operation at Yunjinghong, the use of mechanized shipping on the river developed very slowly. The first steamship was introduced in 1962, and the use of the river for shipping began to be organized in 1965.21 During the 1970s, further development of the 188km section from the Myanmar border to Ganlanba allowed ships of 50-140 tons to dock. During high water seasons, the docks could handle ships of 300-500 tons. By the late 1980s, ships of 300 tons could land year-round.22
In 1988, there were 28 freighters in operation. Their net capacity was 281 tons, and 785 passengers. There were also 10 barges with a net capacity of 740 tons. The vessels were organized under a state-run shipping company with two teams, which were also responsible for maintaining the anchorages and repair shops.23 The number of boats in use on the Lancang remains rather small, but it is important to keep in mind the extent to which shipping is being developed on the Mekong, immediately to the south, and also to the huge inland shipping system of Myanmar, immediately to the west.
In Myanmar, freight volume on inland waterways has risen steadily in recent years. Moreover, container traffic handled in Myanmar doubled between 1991-92 and 1992-93, and was expected to have doubled again by 1994-95.24 (See fig17.jpg) Significantly, even as Myanmar continues to play an important role in providing access to the Indian Ocean for Chinese goods, Yunnan province has received delivery of three 800-ton barges built by Myanmar Shipyards, the first of a nine-barge order. Yunnan has meanwhile ordered nineteen other vessels.25 What will Yunnan do with 800-ton barges? If they do not intend to use them in Myanmar, then the only feasible options are to operate them on the Lancang River or the Yuan River. Will Yunnan attempt to emulate the booming Myanmar inland shipping business and move to containerization? If so, XSBN has the prospect of not just several thousand tons of cargo passing through their pristine forests every year, but up to a million tons!
C. Industrial and Energy Infrastructure
1. Energy Sector
The ambitious plan to develop hydroelectric stations on the Lancang has been strongly supported by the Provincial and Central governments, and has also received funding from foreign aid programs and lending agencies. He Zhiqiang's 1993 strategy to develop the Lancang River "Economic Belt" called for completing the Manwan and Dachaoshan power stations, and the Xiaowan reservoir.26 These are part of an ambitious overall plan to build a series of ten hydropower stations along the Lancang River, at positions ranging 30 km to 800 km north of the Myanmar border. (See fig18.jpg)
Construction of the Manwan Dam, begun in 1986, was completed in 1995. With an effective storage capacity of 150 million cubic meters, and an installed generating capacity of 1.5 million kilowatts, the Manwan serves as a model for other, larger hydrostations that will someday span the upper reaches of the Lancang. (See fig19.jpg)
Construction of the Dachaoshan dam, with a planned generating capacity of 1.25 million kilowatts, began in 1993 and is still underway. The giant Xiaowan reservoir, is planned to have a 284 meter high concrete arch dam, which would be the world's highest, and a storage capacity of 15 billion cubic meters. Construction of the Xiaowan dam is scheduled to begin in 1996, with funding from the Japanese Overseas Economic Cooperation Fund. In addition, the Nuozhadu dam, planned to store 23 billion cubic meters of water that will supply the downstream power stations at Jinghong, Ganlanba, and Nan'ahekou, was in preparation in 1993.27 (MAP FOUR (not online))
The construction of ten major dams on the upper Lancang will have major impacts on the river's ecology, on flowrates, flooding, and silting, and will also complicate the process of developing shipping routes. During the planning process, objections to the lack of basin-wide plans to integrate power stations and navigation were raised by Liu Daqing, of Yunnan's Transport Bureau, Navigation Section:
The prospect of such giant reservoirs on the Lancang River in Yunnan casts a long shadow over development projects being considered down river, on the Mekong. Laos, with tremendous potential hydropower capacity, hopes to build up its own series of power stations along rivers that drain into the Mekong, and to sell the excess electricity to energy-hungry Thailand; however, in doing so, the Laotian dams would further impact the volume of runoff into the Mekong basin.29
As a consequence of its own energy needs, Thailand has a keen interest in maintaining a basin-wide development scheme that will protect both the flow to hydropower plants and water reserves for its parched northern and northeastern provinces. In Cambodia, the unique lake, Tongle Sap, which is fed by the back flow of the Mekong during flood season, has been shrinking (due to silting and deforestation), and raising concern about decreases in the water level of the Mekong.30
Vietnam, last in line on the Mekong basin, has currently set high stakes on raising productivity levels in the Mekong delta, all of which would be threatened by any reduction of available water. The fact that so many hopes for major development schemes are placed on the availability of water from the Lancang (Mekong) is both a cause for anxiety and a motivation to cooperate among the six GMS countries. Only China, controlling 50% of the river's headwaters, remains in a position to develop the river unilaterally, but progress of the GMS economic cooperation talks, and the many agreements which have resulted, promise a much higher degree of mutual interest than has ever existed in the region before. Meanwhile, a major scientific research project has been launched in China, which will:
This research might help to ameliorate concerns that development is proceeding in adisorganized way and at an unchecked pace, but since the study is scheduled to continue until 1999, it will years before we see the project's findings and recommendations. In the meantime, we can expect to see continual increases in shipping and large-scale construction projects on the Lancang for the foreseeable future.
Industrial growth has, until recently, been concentrated in several urban areas in Yunnan. Kunming, the provincial capital, has seen the greatest industrial growth, while other industrial centers have emerged in Dongchuan, Xiaguan, Gejiu, and Yuxi. XSBN has not experienced such a rapid rate of industrialization. The majority of XSBN's population relies on subsistence agriculture and other traditional means of livelihood. Although this study will not address the issue of traditional subsistence agriculture in the Lancang River basin, it is important to keep in mind that the many new roads and shipping routes being built here, combined with increased mobility for the local people, is likely to create profound changes in the basic means of production and livelihood throughout XSBN.
The isolation and lack of basic infrastructure in XSBN has hampered industrial growth so far, but in the wake of establishing rubber and tea plantations, some processing and refining facilities have been set up. There are rubber processing plants and tea-processing plants that were set up in the 1970s and 1980s.32
The completion of the Kun-Luo Highway (from Kunming to Daluo), the Jinghong Bridge (See fig20.jpg), and the Xiaoganlanba Port in Simao is bound to increase both existing industrial production and encourage the growth of new industry. The question remains as to what type of industries will develop, whether they are purely based on resource extraction, are focused toward domestic or international markets, and to what degree local cultures and social norms influence the types of goods being produced.
According to a long-range development plan outlined by Zhao Cunxin, XSBN's governor, and Wu Jinhua of XSBN's Industrial Bank, the new base of transport infrastructure should be utilized to develop the region as a tropical agriculture base, and tourism area. They propose building up a food processing industry and a "tropical ecological agriculture zone."33 Their plan conspicuously lacks mention of large factories and industrial processing centers, and the fact that they emphasize the need to maintain the ecological balance between the existing environment and tropical agriculture is encouraging.
A radically different approach is taken by Peng Yongan, in his analysis of the productive forces in the border regions of Yunnan. He sees the backward economies in adjacent border areas as great targets for Chinese exports (an idea that succeeded in Myanmar.) Therefore, writes Peng:
Peng goes on to outline ways to exploit various comparative advantages between the bordering economies, including exploitation of raw materials, cheap labor, infrastructure and distribution networks. Peng also advocates the repositioning of certain industries from the hub at Kunming to the border region:
Although Peng analyzes in great detail the existing infrastructure, transport hubs, and resource bases along Yunnan's border, and evaluates them for potential placement of various industries, he does not explore any of the consequences that new industry would have on the region. By focusing on resources and means of transport, Peng's analysis is one of the most pragmatic available for those interested in industrial expansion, therefore his proposals for "Yunnan forward-position border processing bases" merits further consideration. (MAP FIVE (not online))
In terms of valley area and population, XSBN's capital, Yunjinghong, is much smaller than the Kai-Ge-Meng economic base. (See fig21.jpg) Kai-Ge-Meng, (an abbreviation of the cities Kaiyuan, Gejiu, and Mengzi), is a large mining and industrial base, located on the railway between Kunming and the Viet Nam border. The area has a long history of development, and was famous for the miserable conditions of its tin mines before the Second World War.36 The production capacity of Kai-Ge-Meng, and the railway (even though it dates back to 1910), are no doubt partly responsible for the surge in trade with Viet Nam since 1991.
Yunjinghong, on the other hand, is still a relatively small border city with a population of some 50,000. The major industry has been the expansion of state rubber and tea plantations, and during the 1980's, the allocation of small-holdings for rubber growing, all of which are intimately dependent upon the tropical climate.37 The Prefectural Governor of XSBN, Zhao Cunxin, cites plantations of rubber, tea, sugar-cane, tropical fruit and aromatics as the foundation of XSBN's industry, and he focused on the development of tropical crops, the travel industry, and food processing in his own twenty-year development plan.38 For Zhao Cunxin, who is of Dai descent, maintaining the ecological balance in XSBN is essential for the long-term development of the tropical agriculture industry, currently it's main economic base.
The relocation of 'lagging' industries from Kunming to XSBN, as suggested by Peng, would have a devastating impact on the environment, and is likely to meet with opposition, if not open conflict.39 Indeed the placement of industry closer to the border, owing to an idea of mutual backwardness and comparative advantage, is novel. If both sides are so backward, then which side finds the advantage? Of course, the entire region might be found advantageous to some other place, such as the commercial and industrial hub of Kunming; however, if the Lancang/Mekong corridor is opened, wouldn't the advantage gravitate to the more advanced economies of Thailand, Singapore, and Malaysia?
The question of which direction the border prefecture of XSBN will gravitate is difficult to predict. On the one hand, the Chinese government is actively promoting idea that the Dai people of XSBN share the "same customs and the same language" as the Tai ethnic groups living in the surrounding countries. On the other hand, the forced assimilation of the Dai people into the Chinese-constructed concept of "minority nationality," the dismantling of the traditional social classes among the Dai residents of XSBN, and also the substantial immigration of Han Chinese into XSBN have seriously altered any conception of what it means to be Dai.
If, in fact, a new identification of a greater Dai or Tai ethnicity is generated, both locally and among the people of Thailand, then the strengthening of cultural and economic ties between them might serve the exclude Han Chinese, and in the long run create the sort of economic and political tendencies that decades of a closed "bamboo curtain" sought to stamp out. The real inconsistency appears to be the customary Han view of the Dai people as a sort of "tribal chieftanship," while the XSBN Dai considered themselves to be subjects of a thousand-year old kingdom. To evaluate such incompatible views, let us turn briefly to the history of the Dai people in XSBN.
D. Endnotes to Chapter II
1. In September 1995, an expedition led by Michel Peissel claimed to have discovered the source of the Mekong above the Rup-sa Pass in Qinghai. The river is called Dza Nak in this area, and is hardly more than a streamlet in the rocky high plains. The sure identification of which feeder stream is the actual source of a 4,600km long river remains subject to debate, but nonetheless the trek in pursuit of the Mekong's source provides a useful depiction of the area. See "In Wild Asia, Caravan to a River's Source," by Marlise Simons. New York Times (April 17, 1995): A1.
2. Kawagarbo is the Tibetan name for the mountain, the Chinese name is Meili xueshan. The Mingyong River, which drains down from Kawagarbo into the Lancang, drops some 4,740 meters over the course of 12 km [Mu, et al, 1992: 104, 109]. From Kawagarbo Peak hangs the Mingyongqia Glacier (mingyong meaning "mirror" in Tibetan, qia meaning "ice"). Extending for eight kilometers down the face of the mountain, (from 5,500m elevation down to 2,700m,) the glacier is 500m wide and 73 square km in surface area [Mu, 1992: 108]. This formidable peak has yet to be conquered by mountain-climbers. A recent expedition by a team Japanese and Chinese climbers was forced to abandon their climb. See related articles in: Yomiuri Shinbun (December 5, 1996) and Qiao Bao (December 4, 1996): 26.
3. Formerly known as A'dunzi, this was a major trading outpost on the ancient "tea and horse" caravan route that connected Yunnan, Sichuan, and Tibet. See also Rock, 1947: 320-322; Mu, et al 1992: 100.
4. The terrain of northwest Yunnan is among the most rugged to be found on the globe. The noted geographer, T. L. Tregear describes it as: "Deep, steep-sided and heavily wooded valleys with fast-flowing, unnavigable, and often unfordable rivers... Many of these valleys are 5,000ft deep and perhaps only 1/4 of a mile wide at that height and within hailing distance. Yet it may demand a whole day's strenuous journey to get from one side to the other. Occasional swaying bamboo rope bridges, slung 500ft above the rocky chasm, help the traveler across" [Tregear, 1965: 265].
5. The treacherous Dulong Gorge, with paths too narrow for pack animals, is described in Rock, 1947: 315. This is not to be confused with the Dulong River, 70 km west, which drains from Yunnan into Myanmar's Nmai Hka.
6. Bazi, the local name for small valleys or depressions between mountains, are a characteristic feature of Yunnan. A thorough examination of XSBN's geology and topography is found in GTJJ, 1990: 3-13. See also descriptions in Wiens, 1954 and Davies, 1909.
7. Description of the valley topography in GTJJ, 1990: 11. Details on the establishment of rubber and tea plantations, and the development of forestry industry in XSBN are found in Chapter Six: "The History of Development in XSBN and the History of Ecological Change," GTJJ, 1990: 181-237; and in Chapman, 1991. A brief glimpse of XSBN flora, including a photo of a tropical rain forest giant, wang tian shu [parashorea chinensis], are found in "XSBN, Kingdom of Plants" by Chen Haining, China Pictorial, 1 (1995) 48-49. The origins of the tea plant, which some have speculated first appeared in the XSBN / Thailand region, are discussed (with photos of the earliest known specimens) in Chen, 1984: 22-30. See also Etherington and Forster, 1993; Hill, 1989; and Chen, 1994 for discussions of tea in XSBN.
8. For a description of early river crossings in Yunnan, see "Development of Ancient Yunnan's Water Transport," Gu, 1992. Gu cites a crossing of the Nu River (Salween River) in the 23rd year of the Later Han dynasty's Jian Wu reign period (47C.E.) in which bamboo rafts were made and "thousands" died in the attempt. And also a route used in the Nanzhao period from Dali to Vietnam that took 52 day-stages. Gu must be referring to the Yuan River, the upper tributaries of which reach nearly to Xiaguan, and the lower reaches of which become the great Red River in Vietnam.
9. The historical annals of the Nanzhao kingdom, compiled during the Ming dynasty are fully examined in Backus, 1981. A contemporary Chinese account of Yunnan during the Tang / Nanzhao period is found in the report of an official retreating from a rebellion at his post in An-nan (present day Viet Nam). This account, known as Man Shu, has been translated [Luce, 1961].
10. Of two biographical works on Joseph Rock, one is mostly narrative [Sutton, 1974], and the other mostly illustrated with Rock's photographs [Aris, 1992]. Rock's major work on the Naxi (Na Khi) people, which is full of photographs and descriptions of the local terrain in Northern Yunnan, was published in Harvard-Yenching's monograph series [Rock, 1947]. A complete bibliography and map of F. K. Ward's travels can be found in Schweinfurth, 1975. The account written by Loius deCarne, a member of the first Mekong expedition of 1864, has recently been reprinted [deCarne, 1872]. Other valuable accounts of the region include: Davies, 1909; Wiens, 1954; and Mu, et al, 1992.
11. Rock's expedition crossed the Yangzi on small inflated goatskin rafts at a relatively placid part of the river [Rock, 1947: plate 143].
12. Upstream rapids are well illustrated in a report on a raft expedition through the Tiger Leap Gorge [Liu, 1987]. See also an account of the 1986 raft expedition through the Tiger Leap Gorge in Mu, at al, 1992: 34.
13. From Rock's description of a rope bridge at Cigu (Tz'u Ku), where the French Missionary, Dubernard, was murdered in 1905 [Rock, 1947: 315].
14. Iron bridges, which were built at least as early as the Nanzhao period (746 to 936 C.E.), have been found in the same region. A Tibetan engineer Tantonchyepo (1385-1464) built many bridges of this type, including one spanning 138 meters. For accounts of bridges, their locations, and construction techniques see Takebe, 1987: 174-177.
15. This bridge, though long since destroyed, was the sight of major battles to control the main caravan route to Tibet [Rock, 1947: 291-2] and [Mu, 1992: 46].
16. Although of questionable accuracy, it is interesting to note that on the 1945 AMS map series (later revised as the L500 1:1,000,000 series), for the section of the Lancang River from 28° N to 24° N there is not a single marked ferry crossing. But on the 24° N to 20° N map there are twelve marked ferry crossings, (nine of them occurring in XSBN, three of them marked south of the Chinese border). The aerial mapping done during W.W.II would have certainly covered the entire route, and the northern part was more frequently passed over than the southern part, being situated on the main air route from Sadiya (96° E by 28° N) to Kunming (102° E by 25° N), the route known as "the hump." If we add the well-known ferry crossings of Jinghong (XSBN) and Huay Xai / Chiang Khong (Laos/Thailand), then we'd find at least fourteen crossings in this area, though one might speculate that many more have, and still do exist. For use of the Mekong by riverine communities see especially Halpern, 1961 and Burliegh, 1971, and also Chapter IV, "Social and Environmental Consequences of Development," following.
17. An early discussion of modernizing XSBN and shipping to neighboring regions is found in Chen Bisheng's essay, "Weilai de dushi" [Future Cities] [Chen, 1941: 8-11]. The incorporation of XSBN into Communist China is presented in Moseley, 1973: 113-122.
18. Xiaoganlanba Port, which lies just north of XSBN in Simao Prefecture, was opened in 1992. See "Development of the Lancang - Mekong International Waterway" [Ding and Sun, 1995: 32].
19. Xu, 1990.
20. Halpern, 1961: 32-33. Descriptions and diagrams of upper Lancang Laotian boats can be found in Audemard, 1971: 54-58.
21. YNDZ, 1988: 53.
22. Lin, 1991: 422.
23. YNDZ, 1988: 53.
24. Myanmar's purchases of container ships and conventional vessels are also being subsidized by interest-free loans from China. See: EIU, 1995: 84.
25. EIU, 1995: 84.
26. FBIS, China 93-063, 5 Apr 93.
27. Details in Peng Jianqun, 1995: 55, and Fiske, 1993: 167.
28. Author's translation of Liu, 1991: 512.
29. Lintner, 1994: 70.
30. Jones, 1994: 11. See also "Asia's Looming Water Shortage," in FEER (June 1, 1995).
31. Xinhua News, 19 Dec 1996 (via LexisNexis).
32. Lists of industrial enterprises, including brief descriptions of their employees, equipment, and capacity can be found in Yunnan gongshang qiye minglu. The growth of the rubber plantations in XSBN are described in Chapman, 1991.
33. Zhao and Wu, 1991: 492-497.
34. Author's translation of Peng, 1995: 23.
35. Author's translation of Peng, 1995: 24.
36. According to a League of Nations public health expert sent to examine the mines in 1935, there was a population of 50,000 to 100,000 miners (half of them children), with a fatality rate of 30%. Their labors produced tin exports of 4,600 tons in 1934. For a description of a visit to Gejiu and trip on the Hanoi-Kunming railway, see Smith, 1940: 150-165.
37. Chapman, 1991: 41.
38. Zhao and Wu, 1991: 494-96.
39. The Jinping County Iron Alloy Plant, in Manhao, (on the Viet Nam border at the southern edge of the Kai-Ge-Meng valley), was destroyed by local residents in protest over pollution caused by the plant. The plant had been ordered to close, but soon was back in business and polluting as usual, which provoked the people into action. It is not hard to imagine that XSBN residents also would want to protect their natural environment, since their crops are dependent on specific ecological conditions. See column: "China in Transition," FEER (April 25, 1996: 29).
THE PEOPLES, HISTORY AND ECONOMY OF
A. The Xishuangbanna Dai People
1. Historical Background
According to popular legend and the histories written in the Dai language, the founding of traditional Dai society is divided into three periods: the time before the arrival of Buddhism, an early Buddhist era, and the time the Dai Kings. According to one version, retold under the influence of Marx/Lenin/Mao Zedong ideology, the first period was called the ganlan1 period, a time "without rulers, without Buddha, and without burdens (of class)."2 This period is said to date to before 536 B.C.E. The second period is characterized as a time "with officials, with Buddhism, but without burdens (of class)," and is dated from 536 B.C.E. to 638 C.E. The third period "had rulers, had Buddhism, and had the burden of class divisions." Since we do yet not have written records or extensive archeological evidence to confirm the existence of the first two periods, the question of dating them is purely speculative.3
The first overlord, or zhao pianling, of the Dai-Lue people, established the Jin Dian Kingdom at Jing Rung (today's Jinghong) late in the 12th Century C.E.4 At that time, the Dali Kingdom, having taken over the domain of the powerful Nanzhao Kingdom, still controlled most of northern Yunnan, preventing the arrival of Han Chinese to the areas that now lie in the western and southern parts of Yunnan. The zhao pianling, according to the Nanzhao records, deferred to the authority of the Nanzhao King and was given a "golden seal in the shape of a tiger head" to cement the relationship.5
Though not much is known about the political affairs of this kingdom, which came to be known as Sipsong Panna,6 (or Xishuangbanna in Mandarin,) during the Mongol onslaught of the late 13th Century C.E., the Yuan government established Cheli Military Regional Administration at Jing Rung.7 This nominal claim to suzerainty over XSBN has been used as evidence that the zhao pianling had been brought into a state of vassalage to the Chinese Empire. However, it has also been argued that far from becoming a subject of the Chinese, the zhao pianling and his descendants maintained real and independent control over Sipsong Panna for more than five centuries. This claim can be partly backed up by the fact that the region was never again invaded by China.
Indeed, it was not until the occupation of the area by the People's Liberation Army in the 1950's, when Han Chinese began to know anything about the internal political structure of Sipsong Panna, the operation of independent principalities, or even the local place names.8
2. Social Organization of the Dai - Lue Kingdom
The Dai Lue society of XSBN was traditionally separated into six social classes, from the aristocratic meng, to the slave class, ka chao.
The meng class included the zhao pianling, the princes, and their immediate descendants. The meng class, also known as sadhu, had to be addressed by all of the other classes as zhao meng (for males) and meng lang (for females). Similarly those addressing the meng had to refer to themselves with the diminutive forms of pi (knave) or ka (slave).10
The stratification of the Dai Lue society already possessed a high degree of complexity by the time the Jing Rung kingdom was established. That the zhao pianling, or "lord of the broad territory," was given the designation of a minor tribal chieftain by the Chinese, should not distort the history of the Dai people and reduce their social norms of many centuries to an over-simplified stereotype. In fact, the survival of the Dai - Lue into the present century, offers an interesting example of a people who were never forcibly acculturated into the dynastic Chinese empire, escaping the fate of other groups in the southwest region such as the Miao and the Zhuang.11
3. Network of Dai Kingdoms
Although Sipsong Panna remained outside, or at least at the very periphery of the Han Chinese sphere of influence, the kingdom maintained long-standing relations with other Tai states in the greater region. Prof. Hsieh Shih-chung has described a network of four loosely associated Tai Kingdoms, each with their own overlord. The Kengtung kingdom of today's Shan State in Burma, the Lan Zhang kingdom in today's north-western Laos, the Lan Na kingdom in today's northern Thailand, and Sipsong Panna in today's Yunnan Province operated together in a "tacit alliance," though each had their own supreme overlord, and the people within each kingdom maintained a strong sense of their own group identity.
According to Hsieh Shih-chung:
With frequent contacts such as these, it is hard to imagine that the Mekong River was not also of primary importance for communications among the people of the federated Tai kingdoms. On the other hand, the distinct identities of these four kingdoms contributed to the pattern of fragmentation of the region when Western colonial powers began to draw artificial borders between them.
B. Formation of Modern Borders
For the greater part of recorded history, China's borders remained shifting, amorphous zones of influence, waxing and waning based on long periods of alliance, rebellion, warfare, banditry, or simple inaccessibility. During the latter part of the 19th Century, XSBN's case was complicated not only by its geographic isolation and tremendous distance from the Chinese capital, but by the sporadic advances of colonial powers from the south and west.
Seeking to extend their reach from Burma and Indochina to the Chinese interior, French and British colonial interests launched expeditions into Yunnan. The British sought a route from India to the Yangzi River, through Burma and Yunnan; while the French dreamed of opening a "river road" to China by navigating the Mekong.13 By the end of the Qing Dynasty, both Britain and France had annexed some parts of XSBN, and the treaties which were subsequently forced upon the Imperial government in Peking marked off borders of the areas in question for the first time.14
Ethnographers engaged in research of northern Thailand have provided insights into the partitioning of the region into sections of Laos, Thailand, Myanmar, Viet Nam, and Yunnan. For example, Nicholas Tapp, who wrote:
This observation applies most convincingly to the Dai people, who have found their confederation split up into five different nations, and their people dislodged, and crowded out of their traditional land holdings. In XSBN, where the Dai people had been in the majority for many centuries, the arrival of Han Chinese drastically altered the demographic picture.
C. Communist Consolidation
XSBN was first occupied by the People's Liberation Army in the early 1950s, and was established as the first of Yunnan's Autonomous areas in 1953. The capital, Cheli, was renamed Yunjinghong, a Chinese transliteration of its original name in the Dai language (which meant "city of dawn"). At that time, the Han population of XSBN was almost nonexistent.16
The administrative units of XSBN were set up in accord with the original twelve banna, plus three districts.17 However, the process of setting up district level administrations took place slowly, and the banna were reorganized several times between 1953 and 1958. In 1958 XSBN was divided into the three main admin-istrative counties: Jinghong, Menghai, and Mengla, which have remained unchanged to the present day.
The presence of Communist cadres engaged in promoting the new regime and in administrative organizing during the early 50's, was the first time Han Chinese had taken up residence in the tropical valleys of XSBN. Although training of minority nationality cadres was underway at the newly opened Nationalities Institute in Kunming, the P.R.C. government also recognized the hereditary Dai ruler of XSBN, Zhao Cunxin, by presenting him with an official seal of office.18 The Communist party fully recognized that the traditional social structure of XSBN, with its hereditary princes, land taxes, and social classes, was still intact, and the official policy was to "unite the headmen" of the meng and villages. This formed the groundwork for extensive land reforms, which divided up the royal holdings of XSBN among the zhao meng (or lesser princes), and then with their aid the local residents came into possession of the land they farmed.19
Despite the progress of land reform in XSBN, in 1956 nearly 20,000 households were found to be still paying land tributes to local leaders. The average tribute amounted to some 30% of the household income.20 Even such burdensome traditions as paying tax tribute were deeply ingrained into the Dai people, but they were gradually wiped out during a period of active suppression of ethnic identity and re-education, when those of the zhao class had to renounce their aristocratic privileges.21
Even though the experience of the Dai people during the last fifty years has included the castigating of their traditions, breaking off their connections with the Tai peoples of bordering states, and fostering a synthetic Dai identity as an ethnic minority of the greater Chinese nation, still the Dai people and all the minorities of Yunnan have, in recent years, been called upon to preserve and display their ethnicity and "traditional customs." What the Han Chinese see as traditional are certain stereotyped forms, certain costumes and rituals which they have long associated with a particular ethnic group, and these are now being linked with a burgeoning folk culture industry.22 Whether the commoditization of culture serves to strengthen tradition, or to water it down for mass-production is a dilemma now being faced by the minority population in Yunnan, among whom the Dai are in the unique position of being eralded as a cultural and linguistic bridge to international trade.
D. Ethnicity and Trade
Official Chinese plans to open up the Lancang Corridor often cite the advantage of international cultural and linguistic ties of the ethnic minorities, such as the Dai people, in expanding border trade. This raises the question of the degree of commonalty that still exists between the people who have been separated by international borders and subjected to the exigencies of political change and upheaval ever since. Are we more likely to see unity or factionalism among the ethnic groups being labeled as sharing the same roots? In the words of Mr. Gehan Wijeyewardene:
Therefore we must also take into consideration the idea of a greater Dai - Tai ethnic unity, whether it is being developed as a model of existing phenomena, or whether it is a surface manipulation with ulterior motives. In either case, there might be a fundamental attractiveness, or a new form of self-identification for the Dai people, even if there is no historical justification for either.24
1. Background of "Ethnic" Border Trade in XSBN
One way to examine cross-border ethnic relationships is to consider the volume and extent of border trade that existed before 1950, and how it has changed since then. According to a recent study of the development of ethnic trade:
This statement suggests that there was neither a flourishing ethnic trade, nor a strong commercial network to support its development. It does not take into account the traditional subsistence agriculture and self-sufficiency that makes many of the more familiar Chinese trade items unnecessary. Also, it fails to include as local commerce the flourishing cross-border trade. The same study goes on to state that, before 1950, the border people of XSBN, Laos, and Myanmar had long standing trade relations:
Despite these contradictory statements, we can at least venture to say that there was some form of border trade going on when the Chinese first entered the region, and that the set-up of commercial outlets in XSBN was either concealed or quite unstructured from the Han Chinese point of view. Under the Han Chinese administration in the early 1950's:
To carry out this mission, four Peoples' Trading Company branch offices were set up in XSBN, with 114 employees. Facing the complete lack of infrastructure:
The strangest example of these prodigious efforts to unite the markets of central China with the remote tropical border region of XSBN is surely found in the importation of these items--in a lush rain forest full of bananas, mangoes, and aromatics, and in the towns that subsisted on their own rice paddies and vegetable plots, as well as fish from the rivers and streams, what use would the local people have for old dried vegetables dragged in on a caravan from distant Shanghai? As for the dried meats of Dali, it is hard to imagine them as a particularly desirable or unusual staple, since Tibetan and other merchant caravans had been bringing them along on their tea-trading missions for many centuries.29 In fact, these trade goods sound more like the staples needed by the Han Chinese themselves, as they moved into areas where they had uncertain sources of grain or other sustenance, and completely lacked any traditional rights to land tenure.
The local commerce of XSBN was further developed by an official policy of government price subsidies, which sought to integrate XSBN into the provincial economy and to place the tropical resources of the area within the reach of buyers on the provincial and national levels. Prices were slashed in 1954, 1958, and 1963, with a total reduction of more than 30%. Goods were available in state-run stores at retail prices 15 to 40% below those found in private stores, and in this way:
Local commerce was drawn slowly into the Chinese state socialist sphere in a deliberate effort to cut off contact with external markets. In 1950, there were 21 cross-border market towns, but by 1990 there were only 10, a 52% reduction. Also, between the late 50's and early 80's, local officials who followed the "leftist" ideology were afraid of "making mistakes," and discouraged import /export, which resulted in a reduction of trade in the open ports of some 25 to 60% of former years' totals.31 In short, we can see that up until the introduction of economic liberalization in the 1990's, the sum result of building up ethnic trade in XSBN has been to wean it away from cross-border trade and make it dependent on the greater provincial economy of Yunnan and its industrial center in Kunming.
2. Ethnic Trade as a Key to Opening the Border
In the light of the "closed door" policies of the past, what are the implications of new international re-alignments for the prefecture of XSBN? Since the perimeter of XSBN lies directly along the borders of the countries in the "golden quadrangle", there is no doubt that it will became a major artery for trade and shipping. The question is, what percentage of this trade will directly involve local people, and what percentage will merely pass through on its way to somewhere else? In many Chinese analyses and projections for XSBN border trade, there is a recurrent theme of "ethnic trade," a rather loosely defined term which is supposed to arise from the shared linguistic and cultural ties of the residents in the adjacent areas of XSBN, Laos, Myanmar, and Northern Thailand.
The notion of a renascence of cross-border cultural ties, based upon the persistence of small scale caravan trade and family visits across the permeable borderlines does not seem to have any concrete plan or policy behind it. However, based on the surge in activity at the border points being opening in XSBN, trade could very well take off and surpass all expectations.32 With the backing of local officials in Jinghong, and the continued improvement of roads and river transport, the Dai people might find themselves in a unique position for entrepreneurship. Even so, they must first overcome very significant obstacles in terms of poverty, lack of education and job raining, and lack of capital for investment in their own businesses. At the same time, the Dai people will be subject to a host of secondary effects such as urbanization, dislocation, and pollution of the unique tropical ecology of XSBN. These social and environmental factors will be examined in the following chapter, which focuses on the current conditions of the people in XSBN and their imminent encounter with the world economy.
E. Endnotes to Chapter III
1. "Ganlan (1)," in Modern Chinese means "olive." My inquiries into an alternate meaning for this word in the context of Dai society have yet to produce any results, but I believe that the word refers not to olives, but to a characteristic form of Dai architecture. This assumption is based on two phrases: (the Jinuo people) "live high in the mountains, occupying ganlan (2) style bamboo houses" [Wang, 1993: 321]. And, in The History of the Dai People, we find: "The residences of the Dai People are exactly ganlan (3) style architecture..." [Jiang, 1983: 579]. If we follow my suggestion, then a possible reading for the towns of Xiaoganlanba and Daganlanba, are the "small basin of bamboo thatch houses," and the "large basin of bamboo thatch houses," which seems to make sense in the context of small port towns at either extreme of the traditional XSBN Dai domain. I therefore maintain that ganlan is more likely a transcription of a native word, then a translation of the native word for "olive."
2. This and following quotes on the three early periods of Dai society are from GTJJ, 1990: 147.
3. The entry of Buddhism into Dai society is an intriguing problem. Since the vast majority of XSBN's books written in the Dai language were sought out and destroyed during the Cultural Revolution, there aren't any indigenous records to go on. An early contemporary account of the XSBN region is found in the record of Fan Chuo ??, a Chinese official who described his escape from An Nan (Viet Nam) through Yunnan during the 9th century. Fan Chuo describes a land where water buffalo and elephants were used as draft animals, but doesn't make specific mention of Buddhism [Luce, 1961]. There are other accounts of the Kuan Yin cult in northern Yunnan, and speculations about the spread of Buddhism during the 8th century from India [Howard, 1990: 9]. Yunnan legends tell of wandering monks from India who performed strange rituals and magic acts, such as the dancing monk Luomin [Yang, 1881: 13514]. But the Theravada Buddhism practiced by the Dai people must have entered from the south, via Burma or Thailand, and should therefore be approached by studying the dissemination of Theravadan Buddhism from Sri Lanka. Although there are many differing opinions about the time of dissemination of Buddhism into southwest China, it seems to me highly unlikely that the spread occurred during the lifetime of the historical Buddha, and for this reason alone, we should be extremely skeptical about accepting any dates without concrete evidence.
4. The term Dai-Lue is a compound of Dai, ? which is a word coined (in the 1950's) to describe the greater ethnic group of Tai people in Yunnan; and Lue which is the word that XSBN Dai people previously used to refer to themselves. An earlier form of reference to the Dai people was Meng Lue. One interpretation for meng is the 'tribe' or 'territory,' and for lue: 'native place' [GTJJ, 1990: 144]. Meng can also refer to the Dai nobility (see note 9, below), and in Thai the word meng means: 'town.' The overlord of the XSBN kingdom was called the zhao pianling, which is also commonly transcribed according to the Dai pronunciation: chao phaendin. (To avoid confusion, Dai terms will be referred to with Mandarin transcriptions, and alternate Dai spellings will be provided in footnotes.) Hsieh offers a rendering of Dai-Lue as: "the people who call themselves Dai, live in Lue, and share equally in making their chao phaendin a satisfied king" [Hsieh, 1995: 307]. Although the term Dai was initially accepted by the Dai people as an improvement over, Pai yi, (a pejorative Chinese term,) it lumped several different independent Dai groups together under one ambiguous label. More recently, the XSBN Dai began to refer to themselves as Xi Dai; while the Dehong Dai people began to call themselves De Dai [Hsieh, 1995: 316-326]. Regarding the terms Dai and Tai, there has been some effort made to clear up the distinction between Thai, (the people of Thailand), Tai, (the inclusive term for those sharing Tai ethnicity, or the greater Thai), and Dai (a term concocted as a label for a "minority nationality" people by the Chinese). Further discussion of this difficult, but crucial subject is found in Wijeyewardene, 1990: 48-50. Chao (zhao), was a "ruler" or "king." Phaendin (pian ling), meant roughly "the broad land," or "the entire land." See also the "Role of the chao phaendin: Ethnic Identity as Subjecthood" in Hsieh, 1995: 303-307. The Kingdom of Jin Dian, or "Kingdom of the Golden Temple," was located at Jing Rung, the place variously known as: Kenghong, Chiengrung, Xieng Hong, Cheli, and Jingdong. See MZYJ, 1958: 254; Lebar, 1964: 210; and Zang, 1966: 417.
5. Hsieh, 1995: 308-309.
6. Sipsong Panna, or the "twelve banna," has been variously explained as referring to twelve regions, fiefdoms, or taxable lands. Sipsong is the Thai word for the number 'twelve.' It's unclear whether ban refers to the Thai word for 'house' (ban), or 'thousand' (pan). Na is generally accepted as referring to 'land, field.' As a geographic name, Sipsong Panna has a parallel in the Sip Song Chao Thai of Northern Viet Nam. A discussion of various interpretations of the name Sipsong Panna is found in Lebar, 1964: 210-211.
7. Zang, 1966: 417.
8. Hsieh, 1995: 313-314. The best overviews of the "tribal chieftanship" system, or tu si, ?? can be found in Wiens, 1967: 213-228; Huang, 1968; Yu, 1968; and Lombard-Salmon, 1972. Descriptions of the Mongol and Ming conquests of Yunnan, and the general state of carnage and chaos that these entailed are found in Lighte, 1981:83-85.
9. Author's translation from MZYJ, 1958: 256. Meng, (or muong) being the name for the noble class, also referred to the areas under their dominion, which were ruled by zhao meng. The entire area of XSBN was, at one time, divided among more than thirty zhao meng, and under each zhao meng were smaller local administrations down to the level of villages. The lower ranking headmen of outlying and mountainous areas were called huoxi and man. The titles meng and man are still the most common of place names in XSBN. See also: GTJJ, 1990: 148.
10. Below meng, the weng class included the extended family of the zhao pianling, their relatives and descendants. Both the weng and meng classes were supported by taxes collected from farmers, who lived on the hereditary taxable lands of the nobility, on rented plots, on sharecropped plots, or worked as slaves on the land of their designated masters.
The lu lang dao ba, composing the third class, were originally descendants of the second class and often became headmen of meng or smaller local administrations. Most of the headmen had enfoeffments or taxable lands also, and were primarily responsible for supervising agricultural production and collecting taxes to be handed over to the nobility.
The fourth social class, the Dai meng, sometimes called gun ben meng, were the earliest residents of the XSBN territory, occupying a fairly large amount of the land. The fifth class were the Dai ling nan, or gun ling nan, which were divided into two major groups. The first group were those immediately subordinate to the zhao pianling, and were called ling nan nai (nai meaning "internal"). The second group were those subordinate to other nobility and officials, and were called ling nan nuo (nuo meaning "external").
The sixth class was that of ka zhao, also called hong hai long. Hong hai referred to landless persons of any class who did not farm, while the hong hai long were those landless peasants of the lowest social class who served as slaves. The ka hen were the household slaves of the zhao pianling, over whom was a supervisory class of slaves called meng. The meng were usually made slaves after being captured in battle, or as a punishment for a crime. If the meng slaves transgressed a second time they were sentenced to death. During the 40's three meng were beheaded according to this custom in Mengla. This description of the Dai social classes in XSBN is drawn from MZYJ, 1958: 254-60.
11. Descriptions of the violent absorption of neighboring Guizhou and subsequent Miao rebellions are fully documented in Lombard-Salmon, 1972.
12. Hsieh, 1995: 306.
13. On the French dream of opening the Mekong, see deCarne, 1872, and Hafner, et al, 1983. On the British / French rivalry in the Mekong region, see also Hirshfield, 1968. A detailed study of the British parliamentary debates on the Burma - Yunnan railroad is found in Chandran, 1971.
14. Details on the geography and demarcation of the Burmese border are found in Zhang, 1937. In 1897, the French took one of the banna, including the towns of Mengwu and Wude, incorporating them into Laos. These remain in present-day Laos (22° 15'N by 101° 50'E) [GTJJ, 1990: 144].
15. Tapp, 1990: 149.
16. Moseley, 1973: 66. After 1950 there was a flood of Han immigration into XSBN, and by 1956 there were some 18,000 Han residents; by 1982, the Han population had surged to 185,000 [GTJJ, 1990: 140]. Prof. E.C. Chapman noted that the expansion of rubber plantations along the border areas of Yunnan allowed the Han Chinese to strengthen their position in an area formerly dominated by a non-Han population. Though numbering only a few hundred in 1940, "...by 1988, after a rapid in-migration of Han Chinese from Kunming and beyond, the total population had grown to 700,000, of whom one-third were said to be Han Chinese....one-third comprised people from 12 other minorities, and one third were Dai" [Chapman, 1991: 41]. See also YNDZ, 1988: 5, 43.
17. Officially, there were four administrative districts in 1949: Cheli, Fohai, Nanjiao, and Zhenyue. In 1953 they were dissolved and the prefectural administration was set up with twelve banna: Banna Jinghong, Banna Menghai, Banna Mengwang, Banna Yiwu, Banna Mengpeng, Banna Menghun, Banna Mengzhe, Banna Mengyang, Banna Mengla, Banna Menglun, Banna Meng'a, Banna Mandun; and three districts: (1) Gelan and Hani People's Autonomous District, (2) Yiwu Yao People's Autonomous District, and (3) the Bulang Mountain Bulang People's Autonomous District [YNDZ, 1988: 4].
18. Zhao's acceptance speech reads like a tract from Communist propaganda office, demonstrating his ability to adapt to circumstances. The support of the preferred Chinese policy also conforms to the traditional pattern of Dai-Han political relations, as described by Prof. Hsieh. However, "...in jeopardy of losing their ethnic-state, the Tai were still following, at the time of the struggle between the Nationalists and
Communists, their accustomed practice of supporting either of those two powerful Chinese regimes. They thought this was the only way for the Tai state to survive, not
realizing that their ability to decide their own ethnic-political fate had disappeared forever" [Hsieh, 1995: 325]. For a partial translation of Zhao's speech, see Moseley, 1973: 114. Zhao went on to serve as Prefect of XSBN for the next forty years! See also Zhao and Wu, 1991.
19. Moseley, 1973: 116-17.
20. GTJJ, 1990: 150.
21. From 1957 until the end of the Cultural Revolution, the Dai were involved in the same class struggles and re-education that held sway throughout China [Hsieh, 1995: 326-27].
22. See for example, the "ethnic" souvenir factories described in Swain, 1995.
23. Wijeyewardene, 1990: 71.
24. Take for example the metamorphosis of the Dai opinion of "brutal Siamese" to a new-found interest in Thailand as "a great and wealthy Buddhist country." Meanwhile the Lue people in Thailand, according to Hsieh, maintain a hostility to Thai-Siamese, while fondly picturing their relationship with the Lue "homeland" in Sipsong Panna [Hsieh, 1995: 328].
25. Author's translation of GTJJ, 1990: 231.
26. Author's translation of GTJJ, 1990: 236.
27. Author's translation of GTJJ, 1990: 232.
28. Author's translation of GTJJ, 1990: 232.
29. Hill, 1989.
30. Author's translation from GTJJ, 1990: 233. Despite the price subsidies, border trade seemed to account for the greater part of local commerce well into the 1950's. As reported in Commerce in the Tai Autonomous Region of Sipsong Panna, "Before Liberation, almost all of the Sipsong Panna market was taken up by foreign trade. At that time a relatively large amount of barter in tea, camphor, etc. was done with Thailand....Apart from trading in salt, tea and cigarettes, in the latter half of 1950, 90% of the remaining trade of the Fohai Branch Trading Corporation (which included...Cheli, Daluo, and Menglong) was made up of imported commodities..." See Narramore, 1988: 9-10.
31. "...owing to the influence of leftist ideology" youyu zuo di sixiang yingxiang [GTJJ, 1990: 236]; "cadres in the commercial units were afraid of making mistakes" shangye bumen di tongzhi pa fan cuowu [GTJJ, 1990: 237].
32. A brief description is found in "The Thriving Yunnan Border Trade." China Pictorial. 4 (1993): 8-11.
SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES OF DEVELOPMENT
Despite the tremendous changes that the opening of the Lancang (Mekong) corridor promises to bring to XSBN, surprisingly little has been said about the social and environmental impacts that the development will bring to the entire prefecture. Many of the articles published on the subject are written from a top-down point of view, examining the policies and loosely defined prospects for economic integration, without mentioning much, if anything, about the conditions on the ground. On the other hand, there are some articles which show a greater sensitivity to basic problems facing the local society of XSBN, and some comparison and contrast of these points of view will help to illustrate the basic situation of XSBN's residents.
A. Labor Issues in the Border Region
On the subject of skilled labor in XSBN, we find it characterized as unskilled and uneducated:
Therefore, from very the start, the local people remain largely unprepared for the increased pace of modernization, and their lack of technical training will tend to exclude them from new job opportunities.
Liu Zhi, who works in the Yunnan Academy of Social Sciences, expresses his sympathy, urging that the problem should be addressed by organizing and actively training the local people in science and technical skills. He advocates on-the-job training and exchanging technical personnel with other agencies, as well as the establishment of a GMS network for consultation, technology transfer, and exchange of information.2
By contrast, Peng Yong'an, sees an economic comparative advantage in the backwardness of border residents.
Thus, the local residents are supposed to be useful as cultural connections for business, and at the same time, cheap labor. It is precisely the search for economic advantage in opening XSBN that poses the most serious challenge to the local population. The fact that their labor is cheap and unskilled does not appear to promise any real economic growth, as far as they are concerned.
B. Poverty and Economic Development
The issue of real poverty, and its alleviation by means of "development," is a controversial subject. No less so in Yunnan, where inaccessible areas still have a very high percentage of people who are practicing subsistence agriculture. In the eyes of many economists, because subsistence farmers have no measurable GNP, they are said to be living in dire poverty. According to Liu Zhi, the border region accounts for some 50% of Yunnan's total land area, 50% of Yunnan's land under cultivation, and 40% of the province's population; and yet in 1989, the border region's income accounted for only 28% of the provincial total, and expenditures only 15%. Of the 41 most impoverished counties in Yunnan, 23 were in border prefectures. "In recent years, the gap between border ethnic areas and economic zones is continuing to widen."4
However, it should not be assumed that the problem has gone unnoticed by the Yunnan Provincial government. In fact, their continued efforts to address the urban / rural income gap, and huge investments in building up the transport infrastructure,5 have been instrumental in solidifying the economic relations between the industrial and financial hub of Kunming and the border regions. For example, when procurements of agricultural products dropped in the first half of 1990 (by 5.7% compared to the previous year), rural residents had no money to purchase consumer goods. In August 1990, the Provincial government enacted emergency measures to boost the sluggish economy. Limits were removed on the purchase of agricultural staples, warehouses were set up, and protective prices established for certain items such as rubber, pepper, and star anise. In addition, policies were enacted to market industrial goods in rural areas. A fixed proportion of goods that were in short supply would go to rural markets. These measures reportedly reversed the economic slowdown, and in any case, they demonstrate the attention that the Provincial government pays to the interdependence of rural and urban economic growth.6
1. Strategies for Economic Growth
In 1991, the Yunnan government held a Development Strategy Conference in order to address the uneven geographic distribuition of economic growth in the province. The conference came up with four strategies, summarized roughly as follows:
Goal: To bring the remote, backward, and poverty-stricken areas up to a higher standard of living.
Strategy Rejected: The mountains of 69 out of 128 counties are too inaccessible. Additionally, the variations in climate, soils, and agricultural conditions are too diverse to address without overly complex analysis.
2. Develop minority regions and border regions
Goal: By making use of existing ethnic cohesion, develop along community lines. In addition, take advantage of language and cultural connections to increase international exchange with bordering countries.
Strategy Rejected: The needs and interests of Yunnan's ethnic minorities are too diverse to reach a consensus on projects and funding.
3. Develop western Yunnan
Goal: To bring the very poor western counties up to the standard of living of the more prosperous eastern plateau region.
Strategy Rejected: Impassable mountains and no infrastructure.
Goal: Zones would be established, each based on an urban industrial and communications center. Materials and labor from the countryside would be absorbed by the industrial center, while money, jobs, and infrastructure would radiate outward.7
Though not formally agreed upon, the last strategy has been the model for economic development in Yunnan. It is simply another example of the growth-pole model that has been widely applied in underdeveloped regions in order to promote economic growth. This strategy reflects the tack being taken in China since the economic reforms of the 1980's, when the "open door" policy permitted regional disparities in trade, investment and technological innovation. As applied in China, the idea is to allow coastal areas to exploit their advantages and develop a highly skilled labor force, superior management, and to absorb advanced technology. According to a theory dubbed the "ladder step doctrine," the coastal cities would act as growth poles and then diffuse technology and skills throughout the mainland. There was, however, an "anti-ladder step doctrine," which argued that the interior regions must receive equal development investments in order to exploit energy and resources needed for industrial production in coastal areas. The "anti-ladder" advocates felt that interior regions would never achieve "take-off" by diffusion.8
The idea that economic growth will naturally diffuse across the region is especially problematic in the rugged mountain regions of Yunnan. Whether cut off by snowfall and avalanches, as the northwest region often is, or plagued with malaria and tropical fevers, as is the case in XSBN, Yunnan's border areas have forever been some of the most inaccessible spots on earth. Although traditional caravan trade, and shipping by pirogue linked XSBN with neighboring regions in Burma, Thailand, and Laos, these relations were seasonal and largely dependent weather conditions. The massive Chinese road-building projects of the last several decades, and more recently, the opening of regional airports, have reduced delays caused by rain and flooding, and consequently have greatly increased contacts between local people in Yunnan and the "outside" world.
2. The Transport Network as a Key to Growth
Provincial investments in transport and communications infrastructure have also increased dramatically in recent years. In 1992, investments were up 130% over the previous year,9 and in 1993 the governor, He Zhiqiang, made public a plan to invest 10 billion RMB (US$ 1.2 billion) in transport and communication networks.10 The push to improve the province-wide transport network in Yunnan has been accelerating, and at the same time GMS plans call for linking up land, water, and air communications with surrounding nations. Though the effects of improved and expanded road networks, such as the Kunming/Daluo highway in XSBN, are just beginning to emerge, we can also compare the findings of research conducted in similar geographic and ethnically diverse contexts, such as those found in northern Thailand.
For example, when evaluating the numerous highland development projects conducted in Thailand during the 1960's and 1970's, Peter and Sally Kunstadter found:
Surely the same social forces are at work in XSBN, mobilizing sections of the population which previously had no access to border markets or urban areas. Will this tend to alleviate rural poverty, or will it create new problems?
An example of the social impact caused by opening the Lancang River is found in a study by Liu Daqing, of Yunnan's Transport Bureau, Navigation Section:
Although Liu's example purports to show the beneficial effects of opening river traffic to remote villages, it also begs several questions. First, is the shift from subsistence economy to cash economy always beneficial for the local people? And second, assuming that there is a strong incentive to cash in on the river traffic, what about the communities more than 20 km from the river's edge? Will they also want to relocate? What about communities 50 km away, or even 100 km distant? It should be worth observing the distance that communities are willing to travel to get near the water's edge and grow cash crops to load onto passing boats. What springs to mind is not the convenience of an isolated community moving down the side of a mountain, but of a mad rush to colonize the river's edge, a competition for limited amounts of cultivable land among ten million people, and in short, a nightmare of agricultural run-off, erosion, and wastewater in areas that have no facilities. The picture really is beginning to look like an "Oriental Danube" after all, but not the sort of Danube the promoters are envisioning.
C. The Trend Toward Urbanization
As the road network connects remote areas in southwest Yunnan with the Lancang River and other transport hubs, increased mobility will bring more and more people to regional markets, towns, and cities. The movement of population, as noted by the Kunstadters, will have concomitant effects on the local society. In the area around Pa Pae village, in northwest Thailand, where an all-weather road was completed along an ancient caravan route, there was a rapid substitution of plastic goods for traditional water-resistant materials. The local residents began to purchase manufactured goods in place of their own hand-made goods, and rapidly assimilated elements of consumer culture which they hadn't experienced before.
The same phenomena are already evident in the cities of Yunnan. Increased opportunities for earnings only serve to quicken the pace of change, drawing more people into the city, and creating a local variation of the "floating population" problem, which has sent an estimated 100 million people in search of jobs throughout China.14 Yunjinghong, being the main intersection of air, highway and river traffic, is becoming the hub of XSBN.
The Jinghong Airport opened in 1990, taking over the old Simao route. By mid-1995 the airport was handling 52 flights per week. During the same five-year period, the airport handled 600,000 passengers, 240,000 of them in 1994 alone.15 To this booming domestic service, Jinghong Airport added an international route to Bangkok in April 1996, becoming the second airport in Yunnan open to foreign aircraft.16
For a city the size of Yunjinghong (with an estimated population of 50,000), the presence of an airport handling a quarter of a million arrivals and departures every year signals a huge impact on the urban environment. Needs are created for transportation to and from the airport, for lodging, and for restaurants, where previously they didn't exist. According to the Omnibus of Economy and Trade in Yunnan's Border Region, the first Dai restaurant in Yunjinghong did not open for business until 1986, and by 1993 there were 19 Dai cuisine restaurants crowded together along the same street, "creating a great ambiance for Yunjinghong."17
New arrivals, traffic, commerce, and affluence are transforming both social forms and architectural forms. Traditional Dai houses, which were built on raised platforms, had single rooms, tall thatched rooves, and stalls for livestock built on the ground beneath them (See fig22.jpg) are being replaced by new forms of housing. Some are built from heavier timber, instead of bamboo and thatch, with separate rooms and modern appliances upstairs, as well as divided grain storage areas and pens below. The most modern, "third generation" Dai houses, are made of brick, with separate bedrooms, kitchens and living rooms, and seem to have consigned the creaking bamboo platforms, with all their charms and hassles, to the realm of memory.18 These architectural innovations are in stark contrast to local tradition in XSBN, where:
Today, some of these huts have been taken down and replaced with an international airport capable of landing Boeing 737's. The urban forms of Yunjinghong are facing sudden extinction, as investments pour in, seemingly from nowhere, and transform the landscape into something the local residents might have seen on television. Symbolic of these changes is the opening of a four-storey tall department store, now being renovated by a Thai oil company.20 Presumably the people of Yunjinghong will no longer have to wait for policy decisions in Kunming to find manufactured goods, but it remains to be seen if a foreign joint venture store will stock merchandise that they can afford to buy.
These changes in Yunjinghong will radiate outward, impacting satellite towns. For example, Manjinglan, a 'tourism development zone' of 6.8 square km, has been set up on the outskirts of town,21 and is reportedly a great success, both commercially and in preserving local architectural forms.22 Nonetheless, the evidence suggests that the future of XSBN will see new styles and materials for construction, and new architectural forms that will alter the landscape. In addition, urbanization will produce conflicts over land for new construction, as well as generate noise, air, and water pollution for populations unused to dealing with such problems. What we are seeing in XSBN, is not a "frontier" economy, as much as a self-contained region being thrown open to the forces of the world market, and forced to shape a new identity as it grapples with unfamiliar terms and conditions.
D. Meeting of the "Frontier" and the World Economy
Building up bases for extraction of gems and minerals, tropical forest products, and border trade, as well as building up secondary and tertiary industries for processing and manufacturing, all seem to indicate that the lush forests of XSBN will soon be competing for space with a formidable array of capital intensive projects. Instead of a "frontier," we should conceive of XSBN as a new "center," facing rapid urbanization from the start along with the pressures of the world market that will be sending ships and barges to Yunjinghong ever more frequently.
The situation is in some respects similar to the transformation of sparsely populated rainforests of the Amazon into gold rush towns. One hopes that rampant exploitation of the jungle will not occur in XSBN, and yet even Liu Zhi, who wrote with great concern about the plight of unskilled border residents, does not extend his sympathies to preserving natural forests. Liu Zhi goes on to illustrate the great natural resources available in impoverished border areas, and in the adjacent regions of northern Viet Nam, Laos, Thailand, and Burma, including a:
Liu Zhi's litany of valuable woods, many of which stand in government protected forests, should serve as a warning of their vulnerability. Unscrupulous traders, corporations in search of timber inputs, and even local residents seduced by
cash rewards might wreak havoc on the remaining forests.
A study of regional ecology in Yunnan found that:
This distressing scenario is especially severe in XSBN, where the forest cover was estimated as higher than 70% in the 1950's, but was reduced to 34% by 1990, for a total loss of more than half of XSBN's forests.
There are ways to reduce the amount of forest consumed as fuel in Yunnan, for example:
The exploitation of forest for export (including export to central government agencies and other provinces) might be harder to trace and to counteract. A combination of new roads creating access to previously unexploited areas and economic incentives to trade in valuable raw materials might destroy even more of the dwindling old-growth forests.26
Another concern for XSBN's forests is found in the Simao Forestation and Sustainable Wood Utilization Project, primarily funded by the ADB. Although the project is designed around a "siviculturally-oriented forest management plan" and reforestation project, it also includes the operation of a 51,000 ton capacity pulp-mill at Simao, which is quite close to the second-largest operating port on the Lancang River, Xiaoganlanba.27 The mere proximity of the Simao pulp-mill to XSBN's forests, (the distance from Xiaoganlanba Harbor to Yunjinghong Harbor being only 85 km), ought to be somewhat alarming.28
Of course, wherever forests and rapidly developing transport networks occur together there is some potential for degradation and loss of forest cover, but the situation in XSBN is unusual. The historical isolation of XSBN, including the political sensitivity of its border right up to the present day, has kept it out of the loop of inland and coastal China, and off-limits to the economies of mainland Southeast Asia. The move to open XSBN places it at a crucial position, both geographically and temporally; transforms the region with pressures of the world market; and imposes a new identity on the Dai people, who are imagined as a sort of cultural bridge to the surrounding border populations and their nations.
Compare the situation in XSBN with the transformation of the Amazon region, where:
Similarly, for XSBN, we see a unique case of development in mainland China. Where domestic markets and services have been protected, and where many local markets are still housed in woven bamboo and grass salesrooms, we see a Thai oil company building the largest department store. The image of commercial progress is linked to the greater Tai sphere, (in former years political dynamite!), and the Chinese government actively promotes a synthetic consciousness of Dai and Thai unity.
This unprecedented experiment in reshaping the society of XSBN "autonomous" prefecture, is very much a case study in generating a new reality of the frontier, and though there are similarities in Xinjiang and its border trade with Kazakhstan, the Chinese central government has not promoted Uighur identificaton with their cultural and linguistic counterparts in neighboring countries. In fact, quite the opposite is taking place as the central authorities, fearing disunity in Xinjiang, are cracking down on expressions of unity between the Uighurs of Xinjiang and other Uighur groups across the Chinese border in Central Asia. 30
E. Tourism and Opening XSBN
The largest growth industry in XSBN is tourism, based on the natural beauty of the landscape and the cultural diversity of the local people. Tourism brings in not only foreign exchange earnings, but also new ideas, new business opportunities, new styles, and new lifestyles. While the Dai people of XSBN have a reputation for carrying on their own lifestyles, uninhibited by visitors, the sheer number of arrivals and the incentive of cashing in on the tourist trade will certainly affect their social forms, creating new habits, new goals, and new expectations.
From 1956 to 1977, the average foreign tourist arrivals to the provincial capital, Kunming, amounted to some 270 per year. With the reforms of 1978, the number rose to 1299 the first year, and by 1993 had skyrocketed to 286,000 visitors. During the same period foreign exchange earnings rose from 83,000 yuan to 196 million yuan.31 In XSBN, foreign tourist arrivals in 1992 had reached 13,609, while domestic visitors numbered 1.2 million.32 In 1995, the total number of visitor arrivals had risen to 1.54 million, of which 23,600 were foreigners.33 The visitors also generated US$ 7.3 million in foreign exchange revenues from 1991 to 1995.34
The tourist boom in XSBN has fueled the infrastructure projects described earlier, drawn foreign investor's interest, and even resulted in the installation of 23,600 program-controlled telephones and lines for pagers and cellular phones.35 The sleepy rainforest is blooming into a sort of techno-resort on the northern edge of Southeast Asia, with a tourist industry that can be expected to grow as fast, or even faster than the capacity of hotels and guesthouses.
The many concerns being raised by the tourism investment boom sweeping the GMS, such as building resorts in ecologically sensitive areas, the proliferation of golf courses in southern Laos (which consume huge volumes of water and spread great quantities of chemicals into the aquifer), the idea to build a laser light show at the Angkor Wat ruins in Cambodia, and the sex tourism industry (estimated to make US$ 20 billion a year in Thailand)...should be of equal concern as XSBN is being promoted as its northern nexus, and its characteristic scenery becomes a part of high-investment, high-profit tourism schemes.36
With the Lancang (Mekong) being touted as an "Oriental Danube," it has also become the focus of plans to promote tourism for the GMS. Representatives of the GMS member countries met in Kunming in late 1994, and held a five day seminar on tourism. The seminar members agreed on a five point plan:
2) Holding a subregional tourism forum
3) Training instructors in basic tourism skills
4) Training resource managers in conservation and tourism
5) Implementing a Mekong River Tourism planning study"37
In the Spring of 1995, the Tourism Authority of Thailand (TAT) formed a Mekong Forum working committee in order to put the issue on the agenda at the Pacific Asia Tourism Association Mart of April 1996.38 At the GMS conference held in Kunming, October 1996, an idea for a North-South Tourism Corridor was agreed upon in principle. Pradech Phayakvichen, Deputy General of TAT, advocated the liberalization of air routes from Thailand to China. Coming on the heels of the new Bangkok-Jinghong route, opened in April 1996, this can only mean increased arrivals to XSBN and other destinations in Yunnan.39
The international efforts to organize and promote tourism in XSBN are not leading but following the region's explosive growth in tourism. Arrivals to Jinghong Airport reached 240,000 in 1994, which means the majority of visitors, more than a million per year, are still arriving overland. Pressure to increase the passenger volume has spilled over from one sector to another, and has pushed the objectives for Lancang River traffic higher and higher.
In 1985, the total passenger volume on the Lancang River in XSBN was reported to be 320,000 persons.40 The Xiaoganlanba Wharf in Simao, opened in 1992, has a passenger capacity of 150,000 passengers a year. The Daganlanba Harbor (some 30 km south of Jinghong Harbor in XSBN) had a capacity of 100,000 passengers a year. The Jinghong Harbor has a 2,000 square meter multi-purpose service building, can land two to four ships at the same time, and has a capacity of 200,000 passengers a year. While the passenger volume on the river is still less than half of the overland service, objectives based on the stipulations of the Eighth Five Year Plan sought to increase the passenger capacity to 1.5 million per year in 1995, to 5.2 million per year in 2000, and to 18 million per year in 2015.41 Let us hope that these objectives will not be met! Otherwise we will have a river that looks like the average metropolitan highway.
At even a modest rate of growth, the increase of river traffic can be expected to have a serious impact on the river ecology, on the river's shores, estuaries, and on the traditional uses of the river.
F. River Ecology
The burden of increased population in the river basin will pose new problems with waste disposal. Increased use of mechanized shipping will raise the possibility of oil discharges and spills, as well as accidents. Docks for cargo, access roads, and warehouses, as well as new or enlarged passenger ferry ports with waiting areas and parking lots will all pose pollution problems and might result in the destruction of natural habitats.
In August 1996, ESCAP convened a meeting of marine transport experts to examine the impacts of the Mekong basin development scheme. Under consideration were criticisms aired by scientists who predicted the developments will:
The problems contingent upon opening the river were spelled out at the ESCAP meeting, but the widespread interest in reaping tourism profits, boosting shipping capacity, and above all, generating electricity for power-hungry industries, are pushing the entire program forward. In the meantime, we can expect the shipping boom in XSBN to continue at full steam and the port at Jinghong Harbor to be busier than ever. Although the Xiaoganlanba Wharf was booming in 1993, by the summer of 1996:
Therefore, the highest concentration of river traffic will center on the port at Jinghong and the immediate vicinity in XSBN. Whatever changes are in store will directly impact the Dai residents of the same area and their traditionally intimate use of the river.
G. Use of the Lancang River in Dai Society.
The continuing expansion of shipping traffic in XSBN will certainly interfere or push out whatever small scale shipping and transport that still exists in Dai society. That the Dai people did have their own practice of navigating the river is beyond question. Take, for example, the following account of a trip on a hired boat, which was written by Yao Hesheng during the 1940's:
Nonetheless it is still possible to navigate a small boat on the section between Cheli and Ganlanba. Once I hired a small wooden boat to go to Ganlanba. After breakfast, we boarded the boat, which was about four or five feet wide and fifty to sixty feet long. It was very pointy on both ends like a spindle. There wasn't a single metal fastener on the entire boat. The planks were woven together with bamboo strips and the gaps between them were not caulked with lime and putty, so that water was bubbling up from the cracks. It was a disheartening sight. (See fig23.jpg) On board were only three or four of us travelers and four boatmen. The boatmen had substantial builds and were full of spit and vinegar, shouting and laughing for the whole journey.
It was just at the end of the dry season, the water level was especially low, and the river surface was only half of its width during the rainy season. Still, the current was swift, carrying a great quantity of silt, so that it seemed just like the turbid Yellow River. The boatmen did not pole the craft, but just sat astern talking and laughing, allowing the boat to follow the current by itself. In a trice we had passed below the Prefect's market and could just barely distinguish the Damian Temple and the Prefect's offices amidst the density of green.
After passing out of town the river became narrower, with many rocks and rapids scattered here and there. As the water struck the big rocks, it sent up garlands of white spray and a fine mist that soaked our hair and faces. Meanwhile, a sort of roaring sound filled our ears. Some of the biggest rocks had names and had strange stories recounting their history. The biggest rock in those parts was called "Bamalong" and was thrown all the way from Beijing by a Chinese Emperor. What a pity these boatmen weren't sure about this story, and I myself can't remember which dynasty's Emperor was so strong. There were two or three really treacherous places that looked quite peaceful on the surface. One could see but a few trails of leaves roiling from one side to the other.
The passengers of another boat had given up on their journey, and their boatmen tried to advise us to disembark, but we couldn't see anything to fear, and unwilling to show weakness in front of the strangers, we resolutely refused to stop. Nor were our own boatmen reluctant to go on, they twisted their boat poles and marshaled all their strength. After a short time the boat was already flying, as if slipping across the surface of the rapids. Then suddenly the whole boat began to shake...it was shaking like mad and the spray drenched us from head to toe, missing only one or two spots. Water was pouring into the boat and it was quite a while before it gradually began to calm down.
My heart was jumping wildly around in my chest, as if it was going to jump out of my mouth, but my face managed to maintain its composure and held out straight through to our destination. Afterwards, I did feel a little regret over taking such risk."44
Mr. Yao might have been over-dramatizing somewhat, but earlier accounts, such as those of deCarne and Smythe, indicate that the river passage was much the same during the mid to late nineteenth century.
Modern motorized vessels have extended the range of navigation northward, at least as far as Xiaoganlanba. Gradual improvements to the shipping channel, including dredging and dynamiting of rapids, have opened up the Lancang to larger and larger ships, and these practices are being extended southward to Chiang Khong, Thailand, and Huay Xai, Laos. The reported international shipping volume has already increased from 500 tons to 50,000 tons a year. With continuing efforts to blast rapids and to develop shallow draft ships,46 the Lancang (Mekong) traffic can only continue to surge over the next few years, and this will surely be complicated by the local use of the river, as in the case of farmers who take the weekly passenger ferry upriver to find work, then float back downstream on inner tubes.47 Under these circumstances, the chances of accidents and collisions are enormous.
2. Bathing, Washing and Fishing
Although changes in river transport are potentially threatening, they only affect a minority of the local population. On the other hand, the traditional Dai use of the river for bathing, washing, and fishing poses a much more serious danger to the people living along the Lancang and its feeder streams. According to the 19th century visitor, Archibald Colquhoun:
"Some of the hamlets near the river-bank are exclusively inhabited by fisherman; and every man, woman, and child, from October to June, is at work with net, rod, line, or the baskets which are worked at every wier, situated next the fisher hamlets."48
If Colquhoun's observations are correct, then fishing is a year-round activity, stopping only for the heaviest rains and flood season. A more recent study (1960) of village life in Northern Thailand found that villagers fished nearly every day, regardless of the weather, after the rice seedlings had been transplanted into the paddy fields. The villagers used weighted throw nets, bamboo dams, nets attached to bamboo poles, spear fishing, traps, hook and line, dip nets and occasional damming of canals to fish--methods strikingly similar to those described and illustrated by visitors to the Shan states along the Mekong.49 Similar fishing methods are used by the Dai people in Yunnan (See (See fig26.jpg)), and will expose them to potential hazards as the volume of shipping increases on the Lancang (Mekong).
Even greater risks are involved when one considers characteristic Dai practice of bathing in the river. In the early evening Dai women and children are seen relaxing and bathing in the rivers and streams of XSBN. (See fig24.jpg) The Han Chinese have found this practice to be unchaste and immodest, and yet have also created a whole form of eroticism on the subject, so that no story of a trip to XSBN is complete without some romanticised voyeurism thrown in. The sad fact for the average person of Dai heritage is that it must be increasingly difficult to bathe, with a million tourists creeping around in the underbrush all year long.
Even in years past, the bathing practice was never a sort of exhibitionism, as it has often been portrayed. Yao Hesheng, visiting XSBN during the 1940's, described the basic Dai bathing habits in this way:
After bathing, their tube skirts are opened up again and unwrapped from their heads to cover their bodies. As they walk toward the shore, they gradually emerge from the water's surface while their tube skirts are gradually lowered. By the time they have gotten out of the water, they are completely clothed."50
From this account, it seems that Dai women have a chaste, graceful, and delightful custom for bathing in the river. On the other hand, the same author also relates the following experience:
As picturesque as the scene may be, it is hard to imagine in combination with a train of 200-ton barges and passenger boats buzzing along. Should the Dai people continue to bathe in their customary way, they run not only the risk of collisions and fatal accidents, but long-term exposure to diesel fuel, oil, bilge water, and other effluents.
Bathing and fishing aside, the Dai people are also dependent on the river and its immediate estuaries for washing clothes and washing food. (See fig25.jpg) In former years, when XSBN enjoyed lower population densities and virtual isolation, this might not have presented any serious risk, but with the growth river traffic the possibilities of contamination will be sharply increased.
Unfortunately, there has been no mention of addressing these issues, even by the panel of marine experts assembled by ESCAP. As for the GMS projects being advanced, the Proposed Environmental Projects include a "Subregional Environmental Monitoring and Information System," and support of Environmental NGO's, as well as support for minimum regional environmental standards.52 While these initiatives sound promising, they have yet to receive funding or to be established in practice, and still the pace of shipping is advancing unabated. Under the circumstances, there is an urgent need for field research, both to establish monitoring points and data collection agencies, and to identify the areas where the traditional use of the river by local residents is in greatest peril from new sources of pollution.
H. Eco-tourism and Alternative Views on Development
Of the many sources examined in this study, several of their authors remained skeptical about the benefits of opening and developing Yunnan. Five members of the Environmental Research Center, have examined the cause and extent of environmental degradation in Yunnan, and have amply demonstrated the province's vulnerability to deforestation, erosion, and landslides. They point out that the high degree of slope in many areas of Yunnan, and the encroachment of tough, invasive grasses, inhibits forest renewal, and the combination of these conditions only aggravates the situation.
The authors also clearly indicate the extent of pollution caused by industry and mining operations in Yunnan, such as the 0.4 to 0.5 billion cubic meters of industrial waste-water discharged every year. They estimated 150,000 hectares of land were being irrigated with polluted water, resulting in high levels of toxic substances both in the soil and in the crops. The severity of environmental damage being done in Yunnan, led the authors to conclude:
Although the members of the Environmental Research Center made the severity of the situation clear in their 1990 article, the situation worsened to such an extent that the famous lake Dianchi was being contaminated with 200 million tons of raw sewage every year.54 With ongoing construction of new roads and new rural industry, there is every indication that Yunnan is heading for an environmental disaster. How can the disaster be avoided? How can the ecological balance be restored?
One author, Yang Fuquan, of the Yunnan Academy of Social Sciences, stands out as the leading advocate of an alternative to development as directed by industrial and market forces. Yang sees tourism as a driving force for revenue and a source of foreign exchange. As more and more areas in Yunnan have been opened to tourism, revenues have soared. Yang sees the greatest potential in using eco-tourism as a means for both economic development and conservation of the environment. Not only will the rapid expansion of eco-tourism serve to preserve the still unspoiled parts of the province, but it fosters a renewable resource--a beautiful landscape.
Yang's advocacy of eco-tourism is especially relevant to the opening of the Lancang (Mekong) corridor. He painstakingly describes the existing biodiversity of Yunnan, including the rainforests of XSBN, and the degree to which it is already being destroyed. He points out the obvious advantages that such environments have for various eco-tourism activities: forest tours, river trekking, and tours that integrate research and surveying of physical geography, botany, wildlife, and anthropology. Equal attention is given to the preservation of cultural diversity and ethnic tradition in Yang's eco-tourism plan, which he says is necessary before it is too late.
Yang's assessment of the changes in the local cultures of Yunnan are frank and unflinching, as are his criticisms of commercializing watered down versions of "traditional culture" for mass-consumption, which he calls a form of "vulgarization." On the other hand, Yang also offers an interesting suggestion about adopting folk tradition as a way of strengthening ecological awareness. He cites the sacred mountains of the Tibetans, where chopping trees or polluting were strictly taboo. Similarly, the sacred mountains and sacred trees of the Dai people, a subject rarely studied, if at all, could provide the foundation for an ecological awareness program.56
The great Lancang River, and the thousands of kilometers of the Mekong, also have their share of gods and spirits in the traditions of the Dai and Thai people. In the festival known as loy gating, which takes place on the full moon of the 12th month, the people:
Will these small offerings, bobbing and flickering on the moonlit water be scattered in the wake of powerboats and barges, or is there some way to take advantage of the attractiveness of the original cultures that still survive in the rainforests of the upper Mekong?
The question is perhaps best answered in the caveat of Yang Fuquan:
In short, the opening of the Lancang River will bring several crises to the Dai people of Xishuangbanna: (1) the incidence of water pollution will impact them severely unless they suddenly abandon their traditional uses of the river; (2) their new position at the center of a major international crossroads will introduce overwhelming transformative pressures on the local economy, demography, politics and social norms; (3) the general lack of education, skilled labor, and investment capital will place serious limitations on the ability of the Dai people to adapt to their new circumstances.
Although we are unable to examine the extent to which these problems have already matured, the picture we have been able to delineate from various sources suggests some vital areas for further research. A survey of the number of people bathing and washing food in the river and immediate estuaries should be taken, and the resulting population estimates and locations should be mapped. Alternative means of bathing and washing, and a reliable warning system should be developed and introduced immediately to prevent a catastrophic public health emergency in the case of a shipping accident. An independent assessment of goods being transported should be undertaken, with special attention to transport, packaging, and handling of toxic and dangerous substances.59 Monitoring stations should be set up for continuous readings of the river's basic data, especially at points of confluence with inlets, and at points accessible enough to take regular sediment and water samples.
How the opening of the Lancang (Mekong) corridor will impact the culture, economy and society of XSBN remains to be seen. The local economy will see the most immediate and the most serious impacts of internationalization. New businesses and industries will attract laborers, causing, on the one hand, relocation problems and increased urbanization, and on the other hand a depletion of the rural labor force. The development of surface and water transport will offer greater mobility for temporary, seasonal, and even permanent employment, as well as open up previously inaccessible areas to resource exploitation. The long term effects of population movements will force changes in rural modes of production, and once removed from their traditional livelihoods, the culture of the Dai people, as well as other local cultures, will be under even greater pressure to adapt to new conditions.
In an area that was never completely acculturated to the Han Chinese way of life, the Dai people are now being encouraged to make use of their Dai 'roots' to open up border trade. Will they be more influenced by the culture of Thailand, or by the influence of more generalized forms of modernization via Thailand? For example, if the Dai are attracted to Thai language television broadcasts, they might recieve a bigger dose of Western-influenced commercial culture than cultural forms that are traditionally Thai. In this way, the Dai people might find themselves absorbing the customs, styles, and even language of the global media culture, with it's arbiters in distant Hollywood and New York, rather than adapting to the cultural mores of Bangkok or Beijing.
More immediately, the Dai people will be responding to their contacts with affluent neighbors in Thailand. The Lancang (Mekong) open navigation agreement will allow Dai - Thai relations to grow, regardless of the political situation in Myanmar. Even so, the push to open new surface roads through the eastern Shan States, such as the road south from Damenglong to Mong Yawng, Mong Hpayak, Tachilek and Mae Sai, might also inspire a new regional Dai identity. The relations between XSBN Dai and the Shan peoples of Myanmar, as well as the Dai Lue of Northern Thailand and Laos may be rekindled as the area is united by year-round transport for the first time in history. How the Chinese administrations in Yunnan and Beijing would respond to the emergence of a regional Dai society is quite another subject of speculation, but being almost powerless themselves, the Dai people are going to remain subject to greater geopolitical forces, just as they are caught in the center of the Lancang (Mekong) corridor and all of the interests that seek to develop their homeland as the last great frontier in Asia.
I. Endnotes to Chapter IV
1. Author's translation of Liu, 1995: 33.
2. Liu, 1995: 33.
3. Author's translation of Peng, 1995b: 23.
4. Author's translation of Liu, 1995: 26.
5. See Chapter IV. Part B.2 on transport investment.
6. FBIS CHI-91-014 (January 22, 1991): 36.
7. Adapted from translated material in CFFA #14, 1991: 323.
8. Yang, 1990: 240-250.
9. FBIS CHI-03-023 (February 5, 1993).
10. FBIS CHI-93-038 (March 1, 1993): 63.
11. Kunstadter, 1993: 19.
12. Author's translation of Liu, 1991: 508.
13. Kunstadter, 1993: 35-36.
14. BEIJING, Dec 23 - "China's floating population of migrant workers may have grown to 100 million people, far more than the official total, the China News Service on Monday quoted the Ministry of Civil Affairs as saying. Under-reporting and other factors had led to the miscounting of the huge army of rural Chinese who have flooded cities and towns in search of work, the agency said. While official statistics have long put the number of migrants at around 80 million, population experts believed another 20 million could be going unrecorded, it said."[Reuter News Service (December 23, 1996) via Clarinet].
15. FBIS CHI-95-104 (May 31, 1995).
16. The China State Council approved the opening in time for the Dai water-splashing festival. [Xinhua News (April 9, 1996) via LexisNexis].
17. Author's translation of Wang, 1993: 319.
18. "China's Ethnic Bamboo Houses Undergo Revolution." [Xinhua News (April 29, 1996) via LexisNexis].
19. Author's translation of GTJJ, 1990: 236.
20. For example: "Thailand's oil supplier, Tawan E San, plans to open a department store in Jinghong...the store will be housed in a four-storey building now being restored. Tawan E San will be responsible for the renovations costing 80 million baht (US$ 3.2 million)...customers are expected to come from the increasing number of tourist and local people whose purchasing power is on the rise." [Xinhhua News (December 20, 1996) via LexisNexis].
21. Manjinglan, Wang, 1993: 319.
22. Yang, 1995: 58.
23. Author's translation of Liu, 1995: 26. Relying on Schafer, 1963: 133-38 for translations of wood types.
24. Pu, et al, 1990: 55.
25. Pu, et al, 1990: 65.
26. The construction of roads in the Pa Pae area of Thailand, opened up the natural resources of the highland forests to new forms of exploitation. "For example, with the opening of the road to Pa Pae in 1979 a buyer arrived for aromatic Cinnamomum tree bark which is used in the manufacture of joss sticks....The result was that Pa Pae villagers and Karen from nearby villages stripped the bark from trees of the appropriate species within a kilometre or so from the road head..." [Kunstadter, 1993: 36]. Similar economic incentives are having a severe impact on the rare plant and animal species of the Yulong Mountain Nature Conservation District in Yunnan. (See Appendix, Yang Fuquan, paragraph 56.34)
27. The Xiaoganlanba port began construction in 1989, was completed in 1992. According to one source, the port has an annual handling capacity of 80,000 tons of goods and 50,000 passengers [Ding and Sun, 1995: 32]. A second source reports the capacity as 100,000 tons of goods and 150,000 passengers. This source also reports that the Wharf put three ships capable of hauling 80 tons and 150 passengers into service in 1992. If the ships made only one trip a day at full capacity, it would amount to 164,250 passengers, which seems to support the 150,000 passenger a year figure [Wang, 1993: 364].
28. The ADB press release on the project was dated 19 May 1994, reported in Market Reports (March 21, 1995) via LexisNexis.
29. Becker, 1995: 61.
30. Unfortunately, the situation in Xinjiang has only deteriorated during late 1996 and early 1997. A series of events, including riots in Yining (43 30N by 81 05E) and bus bombings in the capital, Urumqi (43 30N by 87 10N) have resulted in a ban on foreign journalists visiting the area.
31. Luo, 1995: 14.
32. Ouyang, 1993: 358.
33. China Daily, Business Week Section (August 25, 1996) via LexisNexis.
34. China Daily, Business Week Section (August 25, 1996) via LexisNexis.
35. China Daily, Business Week Section (August 25, 1996) via LexisNexis.
36. Some US$ 3 billion have gone into tourism ventures in the GMS region, with most of the investments coming from Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Taiwan, and Hong Kong [Gill, 1996].
37. "Mekong Countries Endorse Five Tourism Development Projects." in Bangkok Post (December 15, 1994) via LexisNexis.
38. "Committee Strengthens Mekong Tourism Ties." in Bangkok Post (April 4, 1995) via LexisNexis.
39. Xinhua News (September 17, 1996) via LexisNexis.
40. YNDZ, 1988: 53.
41. Liu, 1991: 509. A revised objective was announced in a Xinhua dispatch, placing the target at 1.05 million passengers by the year 2000. The freight volume target is 700,000 tons by 2000, almost 12 times the estimated volume of 1996 (60,000 tons) [FBIS CHI-96-023 (February 2, 1996): 49].
42. Land, 1996.
43. Email correspondence from E.C. Chapman, 19 Nov 1996.
44. Author's translation of Yao, 1948: 245-46. Compare the following description of boats in Keng Tung (Burma): "The boats are formed of single trees, opened out by means of fire until they are nearly flat; a broad plank is then added to each side. Nails are nowhere used in their construction, the fastenings being pegs and rattan. When complete, the boat is coated with thitsee (wood-oil), which is equal to any caulking. The bottom is generally thingan, a wood heavier than water, and the sides of teak. The boats are usually sixty feet long and six feet abroad" [Colquhoun, 1885: 98].
45. Smyth, 1898: 144. Chieng Hung is Jinghong. The towns of Muang Len and Tang Aw, (also written Mong Lin and Tang Ho), are on the west and east banks of the Mekong, respectively, at 20° 40' North, about 30 km north of the "Golden Triangle," the point where Laos, Burma, and Thailand meet. See also the description of shipping in northern Thailand found in Campbell, 1935: 85-87.
46. The success of new 100-ton shallow draft ships has led to a push to develop 200-ton versions of the same design. See: "Shoal Draft Ships Navigate Mekong River Year Round," Xinhua News, 15 Nov 1996 (via LexisNexis).
47. Xu, 1990: 34.
48. Colquhoun, 1885: 110.
49. Kingshill, 1960: 30-33. See also illustrations of fishing devices of the Shan people (as the Tai are called in Burma) in Colquhoun, 1885: 111, 115.
50. Author's translation of Yao, 1948: 242.
51. Author's translation of Yao, 1948: 243.
52. Asian Development Bank, 1994: 229.
53. The authors are Pu Hanqin, Chen Dingmao, Yang Minghua, Gao Lin, and Liu Zhaorui. See Pu, et al, 1990: 54, 58, 60, 63.
54. See "Pearl of Southwest China Swamped With 200 Million Tons of Sewage" in Agence France Presse (April 24, 1996) via LexisNexis.
55. Author's translation of Yang, 1995: 55. (See paragraph 55.12 in Appendix.)
56. A study of the mountain and forest spirits of the Dai people can be found in Anderson, 1993; and Shigeharu, 1988. See also Appendix, Yang Fuquan, paragraph 58.8.
57. Burleigh, 1971: 2. In northern Thailand we also find propitiation of dam spirits (phi fai). See Cohen, 1993: 58-59.
58. Author's translation of Yang, 1995: 54. (See paragraph 54.27 in Appendix A.)
59. A recent spill of cyanide on a tributary of the Pearl River is a good example of the sort of accidents that might occur. Reuters (March 19, 1997) via Clarinet.
"ECO-TOURISM AND THE PROTECTION OF
YUNNAN'S TOURISM RESOURCES"
by Yang Fuquan
Translated by Merrick Lex Berman
Originally appeared in Yunnan shehui kexue [Yunnan Social Science] 1995(1): 52-58. Paragraphs are numbered according to page and line numbers in original Chinese text (i.e. 52.1 = page 52, line 1).
52.1 Yunnan, located at the forefront of the Chinese region opening up to Southeast Asia and South Asia, is one of the world's fairly large areas with such a pleasant climate. For some 300 days of each year, most places in the province have temperatures between 10° - 30° C, so it has always been fondly said that Yunnan has "four seasons of Spring." Yunnan's unique and spectacular natural ecology and human environment form a rich resource for tourism. The province has six national scenic districts; ten provincial scenic districts; the so-called "first wonder of the world," the Stone Forest; and the renowned "first great gorge of the world," the Tiger Leaping Gorge. Among Yunnan's famous mountains and rivers there are the Yulong Shan, the Meilixue Shan, the Jinsha River, the Lancang River, and others; as well as several dozen beautiful high plains lakes such as Dianchi Lake, Lugu Lake, Fuxian Lake, and Erh Hai. Yunnan has also been called an animal kingdom, a plant kingdom, and a treasure house of ethnic cultures. China has fifty-six ethnic groups, twenty-five of which are distributed throughout Yunnan, the highest share of any single province in the entire nation.
52.8 Yunnan society's rich diversity in human environment and in natural eco-environment augment one another, they attract increasing numbers of foreign tourists,and in recent years Yunnan's tourism industry has continued to develop unabated. By 1992, the income generated by the tourism industry of Yunnan had entered the ranks of the top ten among Chinese provinces. When the Yunnan provincial government set up the province-wide development plan, the decision to establish Yunnan as a major tourism destination was promulgated.
52.11 A tourism industry that continues to grow day after day promotes Yunnan's economic development, improves the livelihood of the various peoples living in the tourism districts, and increases the recognition value for Yunnan both in China and abroad. For this reason, promoting Yunnan's tourism industry is an important matter for the natural economy and the people's livelihood. As the industry flourishes, protecting its fundamental points of durability will depend upon how much priority is given to long-term protection of Yunnan's tourism resources, by conserving and enhancing their lure and fascination. As stated above, the power of Yunnan's tourism industry lies in its spectacular natural beauty and its human environment, therefore I believe that the vigorous development of eco-tourism is the most important factor in promoting our province's growing tourism industry and safeguarding its strength for the long-term.
52.16 One of the greatest challenges demanding the world's attention today is the very survival of the human race, which must rely on the improvement and protection of the eco-environment. Without a decent natural environment, humankind will face crisis on all sides. The concept and form of travel called "eco-tourism," although created within the international context of ecological problems demanding our attention, is (as the name suggests) a tourism movement that is closely integrated with the protection of the eco-environment. This kind of tourism, for a place that is mainly dependent on the strength of its natural environment to build up tourism, such as Yunnan, has all the more vital significance.
52.20 In Western countries, eco-tourism, is a sort of tourism that has been developed for some time already. The appearance of the standard name eco-tourism took place at the First International Environmental Protection Conference, held in Mexico in 1986. After this concept appeared, it had an immediate catalytic effect in many countries around the world. All sort of organizations such as Greenpeace, travel groups, research institutes, etc., adopted various means of promoting and organizing eco-tourism, and at the same time many universities created courses and opened research centers related to eco-tourism. As more and more people became practitioners and organizers of "eco-tourism," international academic conferences on the subject also multiplied.
53.5 Put simply, eco-tourism is a form of tourism with a primary purpose of protecting the eco-environment of tourist areas. Relying on the traveler's actions, the local government, and the local residents, the organized work of eco-tourism combines their efforts so that they form into a single purpose. It strongly emphasizes closely coordinating the tourists with the local residents of tourist areas; and only under the precondition of a unified effort to protect the local natural and human environments would tourism be developed. It would not take up any artificial means of spoiling the natural characteristics of the district, such as blindly building up the district with big restaurants, amusement parks, tourist buses, and so on, which are unsuitable for the local environment and culture.
53.9 From the very start, those advancing local tourism must produce a detailed plan and also produce results which will fully protect the local tourism resources according to the local conditions. The tourists, in the process of traveling, must contribute their share by acting in the dual role of admirers and protectors, and not merely as consumers from far away places. Travelers should both visit scenic spots and at the same time learn something from the local culture. They should be familiar with, and respectful of, local customs. (By way of example,) the author, when attending a lecture at the Eco-tourism Research Institute of Canada's Simon Frazier University, saw photographs of sea-turtles laying their eggs under cover of darkness. They were undisturbed by the (conscientious) eco-tourists taking their picture.
53.15 Since eco-tourism includes both protection of natural and human environments, a crucial point in building the eco-tourism industry is how the tourists and local residents can cooperate in the preservation and enhancement of tourism resources, making them attractive to others over the long-term. In the "Manila Declaration," presented at the World Tourism Conference (Manila, Sep. 1980), it was emphasized that: "The basic strength to attract tourists lies in the resources of Nature." The most popular slogan in the international tourism industry today is "back to nature;" and this makes it clear that preservation of a fine eco-environment is a vital foundation for any expanding tourism industry.
53.20 Looking at the present state of affairs in Yunnan, it's clear that the big push to publicize and develop tourism is already a matter of great urgency because Yunnan's tourism resources are already in a grave situation, facing a crisis of degradation that cannot be viewed with much optimism.
53.21 In terms of the natural environment, Yunnan can open up forest tours; mountain and river trekking; tours that integrate research and surveying of physical geography, botany, wildlife, and blossom viewing...all of these being important elements of eco-tourism. But currently in many places throughout Yunnan the environment has already been seriously depleted, imperiling our aspirations to make Yunnan a major destination for tourism. During the period since the 1950's, a series
of policy mistakes (which flew in the face of common sense) were made. For example: "Everyone Struggle to Produce Iron"1 during the Great Leap Forward period;2 "Organize Dining Commons"3 in the early communization period; "Reclaim Land to Make Fields"4 during the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution;5 and also long periods of excessive logging, clearing forests and grasslands, all of which have very critically damaged Yunnan's ecological balance.
53.27 Since the reforms (of the 1980's), the system of industrial production has expanded rapidly, bringing visible economic benefits to our province, while at the same time creating discharges of the "three wastes,"6 which have been causing serious pollution of our air, soil, and waters. The first problem to crop up in Yunnan was the acute tendency for pollution of rivers and lakes near cities, and the gradual worsening of air quality in cities and some townships. Then, with the speeding up of rural industrial development, environmental pollution spilled over into our rural villages. Since then, consequently, large areas of Yunnan's tourism resources seem fated to pollution and degradation.
53.31 Take Kunming, for example. A famous city even outside of China, with a national-level tourist area built upon the bank of Dianchi Lake...but in recent years this city, which is the hub of Yunnan tourism, has been suffering air and water pollution that worsens every day. The once beautiful Dianchi Lake has practically become a municipal garbage dump,7 which has negatively impacted the character of Kunming as a superb place to travel. Other famous mountains and waters are in the same predicament, having been injured and scarred time and again by eco-degradation.
53.34 According to studies conducted by the Yunnan Environmental Science Institute, the area in Yunnan where the least destruction of the ecology has occurred is in the northwest, the zone around Dê qê n Prefecture and Lijiang.8 These district's resources are both rich and vitally important as tourism areas, and yet even in these districts environmental degradation has been unceasingly on the rise. For example, Dê qê n, is situated in the famous scenic area of "Three Rivers Convergence" -- (The Jinsha, Lancang, and Nujiang Rivers, based on a proposal by UNESCO, was approved and designated as the "Three Rivers Convergence" district by China's State Council in 1988.) -- and Dê qê n has nevertheless in recent years been the scene of forest clear-cutting and severe soil erosion, resulting in a number of landslides.
53.38 In Yunnan's major tourist spot, Xishuangbanna, the total area of forest cover dropped from 50% in the 1950's to 30% in the 1970's, the eco-systems of the mountain areas have degenerated, and the number of endangered plant and animal species have increased. During the past 40 years, several hundred species of plants and animals have vanished from this region, and those now endangered comprise more that 15% of the total. Since the time of liberation, when the area of tropical rain forest stood at 1740 wan mu, it has been reduced to 777 wan mu in 1982, a loss of 55%. The area of forest cover in yet another important tourist area, Lijiang, has dropped from 63% in 1947 to 37.8% in 1985. The ecological degradation of forest species in the famous tourist spots of Dali and Dehong is also very pronounced.
54.5 Rare plants and animals, high plains grassland and lakes, are all vital resources for carrying out eco-tourism; yet the crisis facing these very resources in Yunnan is a major problem threatening both the tourism industry and the livelihood of the people. For example, in Dê qê n there are thirty-one plant species presently known to be national important protected species, which comprise 7.9% of the national total of protected species, and 20% of Yunnan's total. Likewise some forty-eight animal species are protected, 25.1% of the national total, and 49.5% of Yunnan's total. Nonetheless, many years of wanton trapping, killing, cutting and digging have reduced Dê qê n's plants and animals to a sorry state indeed, and some species are on the brink of dying out.
54.9 Another example is the so-called Shen Hu [Spirit Lake], Na Pa Hai, in Zhongdian County. Owing to the blind reclamation of farmland in the past, the forests in the mountains surrounding the lake were nearly wiped out, the surface area of the lake shrank, and the lake's depth became shallow. One priority protected species, (used as an example of an extremely endangered species by the United Nations,) is the Black-necked Crane, which winters in Na Pa Hai. Originally there were several hundred pairs remaining, but these have dwindled to only twenty or thirty pairs. The forests encircling Yong Ding's Lugu Lake are also severely depleted, greatly affecting the entire lake's charm.
54.13 In the early 1950's, Yu zhu jing tian, the famous scenic area in Lijiang, was still a place of ancient artifacts, and dense forests where wild animals appeared and vanished. But owing to many years of wild and excessive cutting, it's forests today are bare, its temples wrecked, and visitors few. Significant damage has been done by the same actions in Lijiang's national nature conservation area, the Yulong Mountains, so that little of the original forest has been preserved. On the Yulong's mid-range and lower slopes, the plants and animals are fewer every year.
54.16 Formerly Lijiang was the home of a number of species of pheasant, one of which, called by Western scholars Lijiang Pheasant (Lijiangnensis Crossoptilon), is presently one of the rarest species of pheasant in the world...(according to Prof. Ives, chairman of the International Mountain Association.) Prof. Ives, with the support of the International Pheasant Research Association, conducted a field study of the condition of the Lijiang Pheasant and considered Lijiang as an ideal place for tourists to appreciate bird watching.
54.19 But to be honest, because of the reductions in forests, on top of which are repeated cases of unbearable trapping, Lijiang's current number of pheasant species is
much lower than before. Even today in Lijiang's towns and villages there are many people who take hunting dogs and raptors to seize and kill pheasants. If serious measures are not taken to stop them, then before long this precious natural resource will vanish.
54.22 Erh Hai Lake is a part of Yunnan's most treasured landscape in the Dali tourism district, but in recent years nearby factories have been dumping more than 10,000 tons of waste water per day into the lake; with effluents including: mercury, arsenic, cyanide, phenol and other waste residues.
54.23 China's second deepest lake, Fuxian Hu, has suffered critical deforestation in its surrounding aquifer. According to statistical records for 1975, the forest cover amounted to only 7.8%, and the broken ecological balance has caused the water level to drop. In many important tourism areas of Yunnan, we are seeing the water level of lakes falling, their surface area shrinking, and their sources drying up, all of which pose a great threat to these rich resources.
54.27 Because of this, if we want to establish Yunnan as a major tourism destination, maintaining superb and sustainable tourism resources, then we must begin by im-proving our eco-environment and we must start this by preserving what we have. If one day it dawns on us that all of our resources have been wasted, then out tourism industry will turn into a tree without any roots. We can no longer be blind or com-placent toward Yunnan's present ecological situation and the continued development of the tourism industry. We must look instead at the various crises hidden within development.
54.30 Sustainable development of the tourism industry depends on the tacit cooperation of tourists and the local community; as for protecting good tourism resources and improving the eco-environment, the tourist area's local government and residents must make a concerted effort too. The message of the "Globe '90 International Conference on Sustainable Tourism" (held in Canada) was expressed in five ways, of which the first point was: promote people's understanding of the environmental and economic effects of tourism, and strengthen their ecological awareness. The fifth point was: protecting the future development of tourism depends on the quality of the existing environment. The purpose of eco-tourism is to promote the improvement of tourist areas' eco-environment by means of close cooperation between travelers, local government, and residents.
54.35 In Yunnan today, we must create and ecological awareness, especially in improving tourist spots, and we must take up relevant measures to accomplish this. The People's Government of Yunnan Province has already enacted some rules for conserving the environment of tourist and vacation areas, for instance the "Environmental Protection Regulations for Yangzong Lake, Yunnan" and others; and it has promulgated the "Environmental Protection Objectives and Mission for the Current Plan (1993-98) of the Yunnan Provincial Government." The Provincial People's Congress also passed the "Yunnan Province Environmental Protection Ordinances." In developing Yunnan's tourism industry we must use every effort to protect our tourism resources and eco-tourism movement by fully implementing these regulations and enhancing our eco-environment.
55.2 In human ecology studies we consider human beings and other living things as existing together in a specific natural environment, and we consider human society and culture as the pattern of all humankind in its struggle to adapt to the environment. Whether man to man, or man within the environment, these relationships mutually affect the formation of culture and cause cultural change. Another aspect emphasized by eco-tourism is the culture that is created by human beings within the physical environment of Nature, and this can also be called "human cultural ecology." Human cultural ecology is another important resource to rely on in developing the tourism industry, complementing, as it does, the ecology of nature.
55.5 According to studies conducted over the last several years by the National Tourism Bureau, and to the responses of foreign travelers, foreign visitors are more interested in the customs and conditions of Chinese society than in scenic areas or famous historical sites. Yunnan's greatest strength in cultural resources lies in the diverse, colorful, and spirited folk customs created by twenty-five ethnic groups. These ancient ethnic cultures form Yunnan's special allure to tourists and provide a splendid foundation to develop Yunnan into a major tourist destination. The recent vigorous growth of Yunnan's tourism, in addition to relying on superb landscapes, was also motivated by our interesting cultures. If we lacked such interesting cultures, Yunnan's tourism industry could not by built up, and it wouldn't even be worth discussing the establishment of a major tourist destination. What we must then realize is that Yunnan's ethnic traditions are really in dire straits and on the verge of total collapse.
55.12 We can no longer delude ourselves with the fame of bygone days by saying: 'Yunnan has a rich, diverse culture.' After a long period of historical transformation, all the ethnic groups of Yunnan have experienced profound change in lifestyles and culture. Because we didn't attach enough importance to the minorities' traditional cultures in the past, those aspects which are the most characteristic and endearing to tourists are now vanishing and changing.
55.14 For example, there is the famous Naxi Dongba culture, which has brought many scholars and visitors from China and abroad to come sample the charms of Lijiang, and has even drawn some tourism investors...it was actually due to this singular human cultural ecology that they came. Sadly, this important cultural heritage and cultural resource of Lijiang is in a state of crisis and on the verge of being lost.
55.17 Of those elderly Dongba who fully understand Dongba texts and ancient customs, there are hardly more than a few remaining; and the young people studying the traditional culture and wisdom from the older Dongba are very few indeed. As for Dongba religion, which formed a major element of Naxi customs, it is already extremely rare among the people. If we don't take immediate measures to save it and revitalize it, then after a few years, with only a few old books and artifacts left in the Naxi district, lacking both a living Dongba culture and anyone to carry it on, a great cultural resource (which has a bearing on the growth and decline of tourism) will be lost forever.
55.21 The situation of the Dongba culture, on the verge of collapse, is very common for all of the traditional ethnic cultures in Yunnan. In many places, traditional mountain songs, ditties, dances and such are vanishing and not being handed down to the next generation. Folk artists familiar with traditional ethnic art forms are fewer every day. As a result, many ethnic youths no longer understand traditional art forms, song duets, or singing contests, and those who participate are mostly their elders. As for some of our ethnic groups in important tourist districts, the younger people are crazy about singing karaoke and dancing in the latest trendy, informal dances, but when it comes to their own ethnic songs and dances they couldn't care less, and on average they appear to be completely ignorant of their own traditional culture.
55.27 Traditional ethnic costume, which is a part of traditional customs that always fascinates tourists, is also currently in a state of crisis. In many minority districts, that many young people are unwilling to wear traditional clothing is self-evident. Take for example the ancient town of Lijiang, one might spend year after year there, but on holidays it would be difficult to bump into a Naxi youth wearing traditional ethnic clothes. As a result, many tourists mistake Bai youths wearing traditional clothes for Naxi youths. The Yeche people of Lang Di and other villages in Hong He County originally had very distinctive style of dress,9 but now they've already been called "bad habits" and abolished. Also, the singular women's clothing and accessories of the Ximeng Wa people are now slowly vanishing. On a recent visit to the fairly conser-vative Ximeng Wa Autonomous County village, Yue Song, the author saw that many women had switched to Han Chinese dress. Except for New Year of other festivities, the Jinuo people of Jinghong usually wear the latest fashion in Han or Western clothes. Looking at the current trends in Yunnan, if we don't take action with some suitable measures for improvement, and energetically promote them, many of our ethnic costumes will become Sinified or Westernized, and we'll be losing an important ethnic taste.
55.36 In addition to the decline of traditional ethnic clothing customs, traditional ethnic architecture has gone through great changes. Minority groups are now universally substituting Han style wood/brick or rebar/cement construction techniques for their own traditional architecture in the hinterlands. Already the original architecture styles of the local people are gradually disappearing.
56.3 Folk customs are an important resource for the tourism industry, but now our most colorful traditional holidays and customs are also on the decline. For example, the biggest holiday of Lijiang's Naxi ethnic group, the ji tian,10 has by now basically disappeared. Also the Naxi ethnic festival, san duo,11 held on the 8th of the 2nd lunar month, is a spectacle which many visitors to Lijiang hope to see being celebrated while among the Naxi people; but sadly enough, in most places the san duo rituals are gone forever. Likewise the characteristic festivals among the Jinuo people for raising a new house, for passing the new year, and for youths coming of age, are quickly fading away. As for the many Yunnan ethnic folkways portrayed on television and in films, nowadays, most of them are organized re-enactments by people on location, they are not really living folkways still preserved by the ethnic groups.
56.10 Each of our ethnic group's most characteristic traditional cultures and customs are daily on the decline. Therefore with an ambition to make Yunnan a major tourist destination, we are forced to deal with a crisis in sustaining our culture as a resource for tourism. If we don't take proper measures and promote them with heroic efforts, then all of our colorful ethnic traditions and the very unique qualities of Yunnan's culture will very shortly become a thing of the past.
56.12 If we can universally launch eco-tourism in Yunnan, with the aim of protecting the natural and cultural landscape, then we will make a great contribution to sustaining the conservation of Yunnan's superior tourism resources. Experience gained in various places around the world has shown that a healthy growth in the tourism in-dustry both boosts the local economy and can be of great use in the recovery and preservation of local traditional cultures. The heart of the matter lies with the tourism district policy-makers and with the leaders of the local people, who must rely on the eco-environment to develop tourism...they must also be conscious of protecting natural and human ecology as a way to protect their tourism resources. They must not see only the appearance of tourism flourishing before their eyes, while neglecting a huge catastrophe hidden beneath the surface.
56.20 Of all the things we can use to promote eco-tourism, their primary motive is to alleviate and put a stop to any negative influences that the tourism industry might have upon the local natural environment and human ecology. This is because the goal of eco-tourism is to protect the natural and human environment by means of tourist activity. Although, as everyone knows, eco-tourism has been called a "smokeless industry," with positive benefits for advancing the local economy and cultural ex-change, it can also produce some harmful effects in the tourist district, such as impacts on the area's eco-environment by the tourists. At many scenic spots in Yunnan, tourists are the outstanding producers of environmental pollution. Take, for example, Yunshaping, at the Yulong Mountain Nature Conservation District in Lijiang, which is a famous scenic spot...many domestic tourists have been littering the roads and scenic district with all sorts of garbage, beverage containers, plastic bags, and scraps of paper, without a care in the world; and they are not only seriously polluting the scenery, but also directly endangering the local villagers' livestock and livelihood. In the local hamlets of the Yi people, many cows and goats have died by swallowing plastic bags containing bits of food thrown away by tourists. Similarly, after Zhongdian County was opened and saw a subsequent increase in tourists, the Bita Hai, Napa Hai, and other famous scenic lake areas all experienced the same phenomenon of tourist's littering and negligently tossing their garbage everywhere. The tourist litter at Yongding's Lugu Lake and Lunan's Changhu Lake is quite evident.
56.29 Studies of this subject have shown that the majority of those responsible for this pollution are domestic tourists. Foreign tourists are comparatively self-conscious in this respect, they place their rubbish into a small bag and carry it away from the area back to a suitable place to dispose of it. This reveals the problem of a real gap between the levels of traveler's cultural upbringing and civic awareness. Because of this gap, we not only must work on the long-term promotion of national moral upbringing, but we must also redouble our efforts to manage tourist districts, to establish and correct our regulations for managing tourist areas, and to make this a strong action in the opening of eco-tourism.
56.34 Another negative influence upon the environment caused by the tourism industry is the pilfering of ecological resources. This phenomenon has appeared in recent years, involving both domestic and foreign travelers who use tourism as a pretext to steal ecological rarities. For example, between 1988 and 1991, at Lijiang's Yulong Mountain Nature Conservation District, there were seven incidents of tourists being apprehended for taking rare butterflies, insects, and seed plants. Masquerading as tourists, these thieves of local resources came from Japan, Australia, Eastern Europe, and other places. Some of them were caught when they went to the nature conservation areas, while some were caught while trying to hire local residents to act as guides or while trying to hire peasants to go and collect the specimens. The damage caused by people posing as tourists in order to steal plants and animal species is significant, especially because by using money to entice local people to collect these plants and animals they have cause no end of troubles. If this continues to spread, then it will encourage the local people to wreck their local resources without regret in pursuit of profit, and an atmosphere of selling off of resources will endanger the entire eco-environment.
57.4 In addition, following the development of tourism the phenomenon of people coming as tourists and illegally collecting and purchasing cultural artifacts is always increasing. According to my own observations, even in Lijiang a number of precious Dongba cultural artifacts have fallen into the hands of travelers from unknown places of origin. Therefore, another important item in the work to protect Yunnan's cultural resources is to prohibit the loss of our ethnic cultural artifacts.
57.7 Eco-tourism is useful for stimulating the recovery of local traditional cultures, for spurring social development, and for strengthening our awareness of opening up to the rest of the world, but it can also have harmful effects on our human eco-environment. For example, the many different cultural concepts and lifestyles that foreign and domestic tourists bring with them are an invasion of the local culture, aggravating the conflicts between local and outside cultures.
57.9 In reference to the sustainable development of tourism, the 'Three Principles' of the Manila Declaration, (passed by the Manila World Tourism Conference, Sep. 1980), suggested this specific measure: to educate the foreign and domestic tourists to "safeguard, protect, and respect their tourist district resources, cultures, and human relations." Eco-tourism is rooted in this sort of objective, to improve the local natural and human eco-environments, therefore the energetic development of eco-tourism in Yunnan will aid in the preservation of our tourist resources.
57.14 The commercialization of local ethnic cultures in places where tourism is facilitated can also lead to its vulgarization. This appears in the form of fake, inferior quality goods being passed off, which also has a long-term effect on the opening up and reputation of cultural resources for tourism. Since the Naxi Dongba culture is famed for having the "world's only living pictographic writing system," and a "unique socio-cultural history," many tourists really like to buy contemporary Dongba paintings by Dongba and Naxi artists. Due to this demand, a lot of roughly executed fake artworks have appeared on the market, which in turn effect the reputation of Dongba culture. In order for the people's traditional cultures to receive the greater benefit from the economy and to sustain their power of attraction over tourists, these types of cultural products should be inspected and authenticated by a special agency, they should be properly managed, and they should be kept from becoming crude and randomly produced hack work. Even while local ethnic groups everywhere are encouraged to open up cultural tourism, they must be careful to protect the original form and unaltered qualities of their ethnic traditional culture. They must not go the way of vulgarization and over-commercialization, which would be to lose the cultural characteristics most attractive to visitors. Only in this way will all of the people's rich cultural resources have a flourishing rather than declining power of attraction, and prove useful to the advancement of the local economy and the improvement of the people's lives.
57.23 One important link to preserving sustainable tourism resources and attracting tourists is to coordinate and harmonize tourist facilities within specific natural and cultural environments---this is also the primary principle of eco-tourism. Therefore when selecting sites and designs for building hotels, restaurants, and attractions in tourist districts we must be extremely cautious. Both the outward appearance and interior should match the local ethnic flavor as much as possible so that it blends in with the natural and human environment. We should not clutter the landscape with stereotypical contemporary architectural forms or tourist attractions that are incompatible with the nature of local cultures. That sort of tourist facility, trending toward other western or domestic models, will, on the contrary, reduce the power to attract tourists. In this light, many knowledgeable scholars from around the world have strongly disapproved of building modernized hotels and tourist attractions in the hinterlands of the Yulong Mountain Scenic District near Lijiang; they believe that this sort of construction can only worsen pollution in the scenic area and that is not in harmony with the natural scenery of the Yulong Mountains. The author has also heard many foreign scholars and travelers say that if they wanted to play golf, there was no need to come running half-way around the world to Yunnan.
57.32 Foreign friends have been honest about the highly unsuitable appearance that has been produced in China's ancient cities of great historical and cultural value---Xi'an, Luoyang, Chengdu, and so on---by building endless rows of modern buildings. They've painfully pointed out: "When speaking of a famous city with a long history and cultural identity, ancient does not merely signify an established geographic position together with a bunch of historical facts. What is more important is that it still preserves an ancient style, an ancient tradition, and its ancient treasures."
57.35 Yunnan has a good number of nationally recognized historic cities that are important tourist destinations. When we take up the problem of how to build up these famous cities, it is worth considering the points mentioned above. As everyone knows, Kunming today is caught in a wave of tearing down the old to make way for the new, but isn't this a greater and greater loss of the city's ancient cultural character?
57.38 Proven successes here and abroad have made use of every traditional ethnic architectural style to build folk custom villages or to build hotels, restaurants and tourist parks. The arresting features of these structures, and the appeal of being in a strange place, have attracted crowds of tourists. The author, while conducting research in Canada, visited guest houses in the style of traditional Native American igloos12 and log cabins.13 They were beautiful to look at, quite cozy, and perfectly suited to the peoples' spirit. Every year many travelers come to these for a taste of the Native American ambiance. In Yunnan, the traditional architecture of the old town in Lijiang, and the Dai architecture of Jinghong's Manjinglan Village in Xishuangbanna, are both successful examples of attracting tourists. To build tasteful hotels or small restaurants in this sort of architectural style is not so difficult to do, as in the small restaurants built in the traditional courtyards of Dali's old town, which have become traveler's favorites.
58.4 In developing the Sino-Canadian "work-unity" joint venture project, (under the leadership of the Yunnan Academy of Social Science and Canada's Simon Frazier University,) the groundwork for an "International Cooperative Lijiang Development Research Center" was recently established. In addition, it was suggested that the center itself should be set up in a traditional Naxi-style "Three shops and one facing wall"14 setting. Many of the foreign tourists who arrive in Lijiang have expressed interest in staying in Naxi housing, and this too offers an insightful guide for developing Yunnan's tourist industry.
58.8 The fate of Yunnan's tourism industry rests on the strong resources of its unique, enchanting natural and human environment. Therefore, to develop Yunnan's tourism industry, we must seize on the preservation and improvement of these resources, and we must expand eco-tourism to the point where the local people and tourists all share a public consciousness to protect the environment. In addition to formulating and carrying out necessary rules and regulations, promoting a vital awareness of protecting tourism resources, and strengthening management, we must work hard to utilize and respect all the ethnic peoples' ecological sense of ethics and their customary ways of protecting the environment. For example, the worship of sacred mountains among Tibetans has made it a taboo to chop trees or pollute in sacred places. Because of this taboo, in the regions surrounding the sacred mountains, sacred forests, and sacred lakes, the environment has been fairly well preserved. Historically, the Naxi and Tibetan people have also had the custom of an annual specified time to "shore up the mountains and prohibit swine,"15 which has been greatly beneficial to their localities. The taboo against taking life among Tibetans has also helped to preserve wildlife. And the Naxi, in their Dongba religion, have a sort of interdependent traditional ecological morality and customs. They see Nature and humankind as bound together into a single set, as conceptual brothers in their philosophical system.
58.17 The beneficial factors of ethnic culture can all be amply carried forward and used to advance the preservation of the environment. In the course of developing the tourism industry we should also widely publicize these traditional ecological ethics and customs to travelers so that they might better understand the spirit of the local people and work together to protect the environment in tourism districts. Once these factors have been set into motion and publicized, they will attract large numbers of eco-tourism enthusiasts. We can also seek related foreign organizations to cooperate on opportunities to further develop eco-tourism and environmental protection.
NOTES FOR APPENDIX
1. Quanmin dazhan gangtietong The campaign for mass production of metal ores, undertaken during the Great Leap Forward.
2. Da yue jin The Great Leap Forward, launched in May 1958.
3. Da ban shitang Communilization of dining halls (ca 1958).
4. Weihu zaotian Mass labor land reclamation (ca 1958-62).
5. Wenge The Cultural Revolution, shortened from of wenhua dageming ?????, the Great Cultural Revoluton (ca 1966-76).
6. Sanfei The "three pollutions" of earth, water and air.
7. The scenic high elevation lake, Dianchi, which sits at the base of majestic soaring cliffs, had become the recipient of the Kunming's untreated wastes. Beginning in the 90's a large-scale clean-up project was undertaken, and a US$130 million clean-up project was proposed to the World Bank. The Xiyuan tunnel, which diverts municipal wastes away from the lake began construction in 1994 and went into operation in Mar 1996. (Xinhua 13 Mar 96, via LexisNexis).
8. Dê qê n, the local pronunciation is used, instead of Mandarin reading, Deqin. Note also that this area was hit by a devastating earthquake on February 3rd, 1996, which levelled parts of Lijiang, and caused several hundred fatalities. Another quake hit the region in September 1996.
9. Yiche clothing is illustrated in China Pictorial 5 (1987): 43 and cover.
10. Ji tian. Festival day.
11. San duo. A Naxi festival.
12. Dong wu. "Winter house," an igloo. Alternate of bing wu, "ice house" (see Liang, 1982: 93).
13. Mu leng fang. As in a house assembled of wood interlocked at the "edges and corners," or a log cabin.
14. San fang yi zhao bi. "Three rooms facing each other," a U-shaped building with a courtyard nestled between three wings.
15. Feng shan jin zhu. "Banish pigs in the mountain heights."
A. English and French Sources Cited
Anderson, Edward F. Plants and People of the Golden Triangle: Ethnobotany of the Hill Tribes in Northern Thailand. Portland: Dioscorides Press, 1993.
Aris, Michael, editor. Lamas, Princes and Brigands. New York: China House Gallery, 1992.
Asian Development Bank. 1993 Subregional Economic Cooperation: Initial Possibilities. Proceedings of the First Conference on Subregional Economic Cooperation among Cambodia, People's Republic of China, Lao People's Democratic Republic, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam (Manilla, October 1992). Manilla: ADB, 1993.
Asian Development Bank. 1994a Economic Cooperation in the Greater Mekong Subregion: Toward Implementation. Proceedings of the Third Conference on Subregional Economic Cooperation among Cambodia, People's Republic of China, Lao People's Democratic Republic, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam (Hanoi, 20-23 Apr 1994). Manilla: ADB, 1994.
Asian Development Bank. 1994b Subregional Economic Cooperation among Cambodia, People's Republic of China, Lao People's Democratic Republic, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam: Proceedings of the Fourth Conference (Chiang Mai, 15-16 Sep 1994). Manilla: ADB, 1994.
Audemard, Louis. Les jonques Chinoises. 10v. Rotterdam: Museum voor Landen volkenkunde en het Maritiem Museum Prins Hendrik, 1957-1971.
Backus, Charles. The Nanchao Kingdom and Tang China's Southwestern Frontier. Cambridge Univ Press, 1981.
Bai, Man. "Historical Relics on the Bonan Road." China Pictorial 5 (1994): 4.
Becker, Bertha K. "Undoing Myths: The Amazon--An Urbanized Forest." In Brazilian Perspectives on Sustainable Development of the Amazon Region. Edited by M. Clusener-Godt and I. Sachs. Man in the Biosphere Series, v.15. Paris: UNESCO, 1995: 53-89.
Burleigh, Charles. The Living Mekong. Sydney: Angus & Robertson, 1971.
Campbell, Reginald. Teak-Wallah. (1935); rpt., Singapore: Oxford, 1986.
Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Univ. of Kyoto. Water Resource Utilization in SE Asia. Symposium Series III. Kyoto: Center for SE Asian Studies, Univ of Kyoto, 1966.
Chandran, J. The Burma - Yunnan Railway. Papers in International Southeast Asia Series #21. Ohio University Center for International Studies, Southeast Asian Program, 1971.
Chapman, E.C. "Expansion of Rubber in Southern Yunnan." Geographical Journal v157 (1), 1991: 36-44.
CFFA = China, Facts & Figures Annual
Chen, 1941. See Chen, Bisheng, in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Chen, 1984. See Chen, Chuan, in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Chen, 1994. See Chen, Xingyan, in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Chen, Fei. "Past, Present, and Future of Border Trade Between Burma and China." Guoji maoyi wenti 8 (6 Aug 1995): 59-61. Translated in FBIS CHI- 95-191, 3 Oct 95.
China, Facts & Figures Annual. Vols 1-10 edited by John L. Scherer. Vols 11- edited by Charles E. Greer. Gulf Breeze (FL): Academic Intl Press, 1978-
Cohen, Paul T. "Irrigation and the Northern Thai States in the 19th Century." In Patterns and Illusions, Thai History and Thought. 2nd edition. Edited by
Gehan Wijeyewardene and E. C. Chapman. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1993.
Colquhoun, Archibald Ross. Amongst the Shans. London: Field & Tuer, 1885.
Davies, H. R. Yun-nan, the Link Between India and the Yangtze. (1909); rpt.,
Taipei: Cheng Wen, 1970.
de Carne, Louis. Voyage en Indo-Chine et dans l'Empire Chinois. Paris: E. Dentu, 1872. English edition, Travels on the Mekong--Cambodia, Laos, and Yunnan. Bangkok: White Lotus, 1995.
Ding, Weimin and Sun, Yifu. "The Development of the Lancang-Mekong Inter- national Waterway." In China Pictoral (4) 1995: 30-33.
Dong and Guo, 1990. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
DZSH See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
EIU = Economist Intelligence Unit.
Economist Intelligence Unit. Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar - EIU Country Profile, 1995-96. London: EIU Ltd., 1995.
Etherington, Dan and Forster, Keith. Green Gold, the Political Economy of China's Post-1949 Tea Industry. Hong Kong: Oxford Univ, 1993.
Far East and Australia 1995. 26th Edition. London: Europa Publications, 1995.
FBIS = Foreign Broadcast Information Service. (daily bulletins, until July 1996, Washington, D.C.: U.S. Information Agency.)
FEA = Far East and Australia.
FEER = Far East Economic Review.
Fiske, John D. China, Facts and Figures Annual Handbook, No17. Gulf Breeze: Academic International, 1993.
Fujioka, Yoshikazu, editor. Water Resource Utilization in SE Asia. Symposium Series III. Kyoto: Center for SE Asian Studies, University of Kyoto, 1966.
Gill, Teena. "Indochina Tourism: Asian Tigers Invest With Gleams in Their
Eyes." Inter Press Service, 1 Apr 1996 (via LexisNexis)
GTJJ See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Gu, 1992. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Hafner, James, Joel Halpern, and Barbara Kerewsky-Halpern. River Road Through Laos: Reflections of the Mekong. Asian Studies Program, Occ. Papers Series No. 10. Amherst: Univ of Mass, 1983.
Halpern, Joel. Rural and Urban Economies, Laos Project Paper No. 18. Los Angeles: Dept of Anthropology, UCLA, 1961.
Harrell, Stevan. Cultural Encounters on China's Ethnic Frontiers. Seattle: Univ of Wasington, 1995.
Hill, Anne Maxwell. "Chinese Dominance of the Xishuangbanna Tea Trade." Modern China v15 no3, Jul 1989: 321-345.
Hirshfield, Claire. "Struggle for the Mekong Banks, 1892-96." Journal of Southeast Asian History. vol9 no1 (Mar 1968) 25-52.
Howard, Angela Falco. "A Gilt Bronze Guanyin from the Nanzhao Kingdom of Yunnan: Hybrid Art from the Southwestern Frontier." In Jounral of the Walters Art Gallery, 48 (1990): 1-12.
Hsieh Shih-chung. "On the Dynamics of Thai / Dai-Lue Enthnicity." In Cultural Encounters on China's Ethnic Frontiers. Edited by Stevan Harrell. Seattle: Univ of Wasington, 1995.
Hucker, Charles O. Dictionary of Official Titles in Imperial China. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1985.
Jacobs, Jeffrey W. "Mekong Committee History and Lessons for River Basin Development." In Geographical Journal, v.161 (2) July 1995: 135-148.
Jiang, 1983. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Jones, Clayton. "A New Dawn Along the Mekong." In Christian Science Monitor. 12 Jan 1994: 11.
Kaulback, Ronald. Salween. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1938.
Kingshill, Konrad. Ku Daeng - the Red Tomb. Chiangmai: Prince Royal's College, 1960.
Kunstadter, Peter and Sally L. Kunstadter. "Population Movements and Environ- mental Changes in the Hills of Northern Thailand." In Patterns and Illusions, Thai History and Thought. 2nd edition. Edited by Gehan Wijeyewardene and E.C. Champan. Singapore: Inst of Southeast Asian Studies, 1993.
Land, Thomas. "Mekong Basin Scheme Prompts Talks." Lloyds List, 16 Aug 1996 (via LexisNexis).
Lebar, Frank, Gerald Hickey, and John Musgrave. Ethnic Groups of Mainland Southeast Asia. New Haven: Human Resource Area Files, 1964.
Lighte, Peter Rupert. The Mongols and Mu Ying in Yunnan -- At the Empire's Edge. Princeton University, PhD Dissertation, 1981.
Li, 1991. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Lin, 1991. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Lintner, Bertil. Land of Jade, a Journey Through Insurgent Burma. Bangkok:
White Lotus, 1990.
Lintner, Bertil. "Add Water." FEER, (13 Oct 94): 70-71.
Lintner, Bertil. "Road of Death." FEER, (28 Nov 96): 32-36.
Liu, 1991. See Liu, Daqing in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Liu, 1995. See Liu, Zhi in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Liu, Qijun. "Conquering the Golden Sands." China Pictorial 2 (1987): 6-9.
Lombard-Salmon, Claudine. Un exemple d'acculuration chinoise: la province du Gui Zhou au XVIIIe siecle. Paris: Ecole Francaise d'Extreme Orient, 1972.
Luce, Gordon, translator. The Man Shu, Book of the Southern Barbarians. Ithaca: Cornell Univ. SE Asia Program Data Paper 44, 1961.
Luo, 1995. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
McCoy, Alfred W. The Politics of Heroin. Revised edition. Chicago; Lawrence Hill, 1991.
Moseley, George. Consolodation of the South China Frontier. Berkeley: Univ of Calif, 1973.
Mu, et al 1992. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
MZYJ See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Narramore, Terry translator. "Commerce in the Tai Autonomous Region of Sipsong Panna." In Thai-Yunnan Project Nesletter 3 (Dec 1988): 7-11.
Nguyen, Mark. "Laos, Back to the Land of Three Kingdoms." In Southeast Asian Affairs 1996. Edited by Daljit Singh and Liak Teng Kiat. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1996: 197-214.
Ouyang, 1993. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Peng, Jianqin. "Yunnan's Hydropower Construction." China Today, Jan 95: 52-55.
Peng, 1995b. See Peng, Yong'an in See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Pettman, Ralph. China in Burma's Foreign Policy. Canberra: Australian National University, 1973.
Pu Hanqin, Chen Dingmao, Yang Minhua, Gao Lin, and Liu Zhaorui. "Regional Ecology and Economic Development in Yunnan." Chinese Environment and Development. (1993)v4, no3: 51-67.
Qiao Bao. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Rock, Joseph. The Ancient Na-Khi Kingdom of Southwest China. 2v. Cambridge, Harvard Univ, 1947.
Schafer, Edward H. The Golden Peaches of Samarkand. Berkeley: Univ of California, 1963.
Schweinfurth, Ulrich. Exploration in the Eastern Himalyas and the River Gorge Country of Southeast Tibet. Geological Research, v. 3. Weisbaden: Franz Steiner, 1975.
Shigeharu, Tanabe. "Tai Lu Guardian Cults in Yunnan." In Sojourn 3.1 (1988): 1-25.
Simons, Marlise. "In Wild Asia, Caravan to a River's Source." New York Times. 17 Apr 95: pA1.
Smith, Nicol. Burma Road. NY: Bobbs Merrill, 1940.
Smyth, A. H. Warington. Five Years in Siam, from 1891-1895. 2v. NY: Scribners, 1898.
Sun, Shirley. "By Rail to Monsoon Jungles." In Journey Into China. Edited by Kenneth Danforth. Washington D.C.: National Geographic Society, 1982: 309-367.
Sutton, Stephanne B. In China's Border Provinces, the Turbulent Career of Joseph Rock, Botanist-Explorer. NY: Hastings House, 1974.
Swain, Margaret Byrne. "A Comparison of State and Private Artisan Production for Tourism in Yunnan." in Tourism in China. Edited by Alan Lew and
Lawrence Yu. Boulder: Westview, 1995: 223-33.
Takebe, 1987. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Tan, Ricardo M.; Pante, Filologo and Abonyi, George. "Economic Cooperation in the GMS." In Regional Cooperation and Integration in Asia. Edited by
Kiichiro Fukusaku. Paris: OECD, 1995: 223-48.
Tapp, Nicholas. "Squatters or Refugees." In Ethnic Groups across National Boundaries in Mainland Southeast Asia. Edited by Gehan Wijeyewardene. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1990.
Thai-Yunnan Project Nesletter. Canberra: Anthropology Department, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University, 1987- (occasional)
TYPN = Thai-Yunnan Project Nesletter.
Tregear, T. R. A Geography of China. University of London, 1965.
Wang, 1993. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Ward, F. Kingdon. Land of the Blue Poppy, Travels of a Naturalist in Eastern Tibet. (Orig edition: Camridge Univ Press, 1913.) Repr. Sakonnet (Rhode Island): Theophrastus, 1973.
Ward, F. Kingdon. "Yunnan and Eastern Tibet." In Journal of the Royal Central Asiatic Society, 1924: 124-135.
Wiens, Herold J. Han Chinese Expansion in South China. (Orig Title: China's March Toward the Tropics, 1954). Repr. Shoe String Press, 1967.
Wijeyewardene, Gehan, "Thailand and the Tai: Versions of Ethnic Identity." In Ethnic Groups across National Boundaries in Mainland Southeast Asia.
Edited by Gehan Wijeyewardene. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 1990.
Wijeyewardene, Gehan and E.C. Chapman, editors. Patterns and Illusions, Thai History and Thought. 2nd edition. Singapore: Inst of Southeast Asian Studies, 1993.
Xu, Liqun. "Notes on Southern Yunnan." In China Pictorial 5 (1990): 34-36.
Yang, 1881. See Yang, Shen, in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Yang, 1995. Yang, Fuquan, in "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Yang, Dali. "Patterns of China's Regional Development Strategy." China Quarterly (122) June 1990: 230-257.
Yang, Dao. Hmong at the Turning Point. Minneapolis: Worldbridge Assoc, 1993.
YNDZ See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Yomiuri Shinbun. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Yunnan gongshang qiye minglu. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Yunnan nianjian. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Zang, 1996. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Zhang, 1937. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Zhang, Changjiang. "The Thriving Yunnan Border Trade." China Pictorial 4 (1993): 8-11.
Zhao and Wu, 1991. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Zhongguo shaoshu minzu. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
Zhongguo tongji nianjian. See "Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited."
B. Chinese and Japanese Sources Cited
Chen, Bisheng. . Dian-bian san-yi [Miscellaneous memories of the Yunnan Border]. (1941) Repr. in Minsu congshu, Zhuan hao 2, Min-zu pian 19. Taipei: Orient Cultural Service, 1976.
Chen, Chuan. Chaye tongshi, [Complete History of the Tea Industry]. Beijing: Nongye chubanshe, 1984.
Chen, Xingyan. Chashu yuanchandi, [Original Locality of the Tea Plant]. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1994.
Daizu shehui lishi diaocha: Xishuang Banna, [Investigation into the Social History of the Dai People, Xishuangbanna]. 10v. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1983-87.
DZSH = Daizu shehui lishi diaocha: Xishuang Banna
Dong, Mengxiong and Guo Yafei. "Jindai Yunnan de jiaotong yunshu yu shangpin jingji," [Transport, Shipping and Commerce in Modern Yunnan]. In Yunnan shehui kexue, [Yunnan Social Science] 1990 (1): 81-89.
GTJJ = Xishuangbanna guotu jingji kaocha baogao.
Gu, Yongji. "Yunnan gudai de shuiyun fazhan," [Early Development of Shipping in Yunnan]. In Yunnan shehui kexue, [Yunnan Social Science] 1992 (1): 79-85.
Jiang Yingliang. Daizushi, [History of the Dai People]. Chengdu: Sichuan minzu chubanshe, 1983.
Li, Zuohong. "Lancangjiang shui ziyuan kaifa liyong yu diqu jingji fazhan," [Utilization of Lancang River Resources and Development of the Regional Economy]. In Kaifa da xinan--Sichuan Yunnan juan, [Developing the Greater Southwest--Sichuan, Yunnan] Beijing: Xueyuan chubanshe, 1991: 498-505.
Lin, Fatang. "Kaifa Lancangjiang -- Meigonghe guoji hangyun dui yunnan he xinan diqu de duiwai kaifa juyou zhanlue xing yiyi," [Strategic Significance of the Development of the Lancang / Mekong River International Shipping in Terms of Opening Up Yunnan and the Southwest Region]. In Kaifa da xinan--Sichuan Yunnan juan, [Developing the Greater Southwest--Sichuan, Yunnan] Beijing: Xueyuan chubanshe, 1991: 421-423.
Liu Daqing. "Lancang jiang hangyun zai jingji fazhan zhanlue zhong de diwei yu kaifa fanglue," [Position of Lancang River Transport in Economic Develeopment Strategy and in the Overall Development Shceme]. In Kaifa da xinan--Sichuan Yunnan juan, [Developing the Greater Southwest--Sichuan, Yunnan] Beijing: Xueyuan chubanshe, 1991: 506-515.
Liu, Zhi. "Zhongguo Yunnan yu Mian Lao Yue Tai pilindiqu de hezuo kaifa yanjiu," [Study of Yunnan, China and Joint Development with Neighboring Myanmar, Laos, Vietnam, and Thailand]. In Yunnan shehui kexue, [Yunnan Social Science] 1995 (6): 25-33.
Luo, Mingyi. "Fenxi he yuce Kunming guowai luyou keyuan shichang," [Analysis and Forecast of Kunming's Foreign Tourist Market]. In Jingji wenti tansuo, [Economic Problems Review] 1995 (2): 14-16.
Minzu yanjiusuo, Beijing. Minzu yanjiu gongzuo de yuejin, (= MZYJ) [Advances in the Study of Minority Nationalities]. Beijing: Kexue chubanshe, 1958.
Mu Jihong, Chen Baoya, et al. Dian Cang Chuan 'Da san jiao' wenhua tanmi, [Exploring the secret culture of the "Great Triangle"-- Yunnan, Tibet, and Sichuan]. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1992.
MZYJ = Minzu yanjiu suo, Beijing
Ouyang, Guobin, et al. Yunnan jingji nianjian, [Yunnan Economic Yearbook].Kunming: Yunnan nianjian zazhishe, 1993.
Peng, Yong'an. "Yunnan bianjing dui wai kaifang de shengchanli buju yanjiu," [Research on the Overall Productive Forces in Yunnan's Border Region and it's Opening to the Outside World]. In Jingji dili, [Economic Geography] v.15 no.1, Mar 1995: 21-26.
Qiao bao. New York, daily newspaper.
Takebe, Kenichi Chu-goku mei kyo monogatari, [Story of China's Famous Bridges]. Tokyo: Gihodo, 1987.
Tang, Guohui and Wang, Yingsu. "Lun Yunnan yanbian kaifa," [On Yunnan's Border Development]. (Kunming) Jingji wenti tansuo, [Investigations into Economic Problems], 1995 (4): 32- 33.
Wang, Jianzhong, Li Caiyun, and Zhou Fang, editors. Yunnan bianjing jingji maoyi quanshu, [Omnibus of Economy and Trade in Yunnan's Border Region]. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1993.
Xishuangbanna guotu jingji kaocha baogao, (= GTJJ) [Report of the Economic Survey of the Xishuangbanna Territory]. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1990.
Yang, Fuquan. "Shengtai luyou yu Yunnan de luyou ziyuan baohu," [Eco-Tourism and the Protection of Yunnan's Tourism Resources]. Yunnan shehui kexue, [Yunnan Social Science] (1) 1995: 52-58.
Yang, Shen. "Yunnan shanchuan zhi," [A Record of Yunnan's Landscape]. In Han hai. Edited by (Qing) Li, Diaoyuan. Fang wan juan lou edition,1881. Reprint, Taipei: Hong ye shuju, 1968, v. 22.
Yao, Hesheng. Shuibaiyi fengtuji, [Record of Local Customs and Conditions of the Shuibaiyi People]. (1948) Reprinted, Shanghai: Shanghai wenshu chubanshe, 1990.
YNDZ = Yunnandi zhou shi xian gaikuang
Yomiuri Shinbun. Daily Newspaper, Satellite Edition.
Yu, Yi'ze. "Ming dai zhi tusi zhidu," [Tribal Cheiftan System of the Ming Dynasty]. (1936); rpt. in Ming shi luncong v.5. Taipei: Xuesheng shuju, 1968: 5-16.
Yunnan di zhou shi xian gaikuang / Xishuangbanna Daizu zizhizhou fence, = YNDZ. [Survey of Yunnan's Prefectures, Cities, and Towns / Xishuangbanna Dai Autonomous Prefecture Series]. Kunming: Yunnan renmin chubanshe, 1988.
Yunnan gongshang qiye minglu, [Directory of Yunnan Industrial and Commercial Handbook]. Beijing: Xinhua, 1985.
Yunnan nianjian, 1992 [Yunnan Yearbook, 1992]. General Editor, Wu Guangfan. Kunming: Yunnan nianjian zazhishe, 1992.
Zang, Lihe, et al. Zhongguo gujin diming da cidian, [Great Dictionary of Ancient and Modern Chinese Place-names]. (Reprint) Taipei: Shangwu yinshuguan, 1966.
Zhang, Cheng-sun. Zhong/Ying Dian/Mian jiangjie wenti, [The Sino-British Yunnan-Burmese Border Problem]. Yanjing xuebao, zhuanhao 15. Taipei: Orient Cultural Service, 1937.
Zhao Cunxin, & Wu Jinhua "Lun Xishuangbanna zai da xinan kaifa zhong de zhanlue diwei," [On the Position of Xishuangbanna in the Strategy of Developing the Greater Southwest Region]. In Kaifa da xinan--Sichuan Yunnan juan. [Developing the Greater Southwest - Sichuan, Yunnan] Beijing: Xueyuan chubanshe, 1991: 492-7.
Zhongguo shaoshu minzu, China's Ethnic Minorities]. Beijing: Renmin chubanshe, 1987.
Zhongguo tongji nianjian, [China Statistical Yearbook], Beijing: Zhongguo tongji nianjian chubanshe, (Annual).